Windy City Coin is a trusted and reputable business that offers fair and reasonable pricing for buying and selling coins and precious metals. The owner is described as a kind, honest, and fair individual who provides great service to his customers. Customers have praised the business for its quick and efficient in-and-out transactions, as well as the owner's willingness to take in jars of spare change and convert them to bullion. The reviews highlight that while prices may vary across different dealers, the owner at Windy City Coin consistently provides competitive and transparent pricing. Many customers have had positive experiences selling their family silver, coins, and other precious metals at Windy City Coin, feeling confident that they were paid a fair price for the weight and condition of their items. The business is recommended by satisfied customers who have returned multiple times to buy and sell. Overall, Windy City Coin is an established and reputable coin and precious metals dealer, known for its honest, fair, and friendly service, making it a reliable choice for those looking to buy or sell their valuable items.
I usually buy off APMEX but I’ve been looking for a local coin shop. Found this one off google because it had such good reviews. Very nice guy, fair premiums, knowledgeable.
June 2025
By far the best coin shop in the area, honestly cannot say enough good about this place. Premiums are all reasonable you just can’t beat them anywhere else. On top of that Brain is extremely knowledgeable and treats you with great respect every time you walk through his door. Give him a stop and I promise you will know... read full comment
September 2024
Reasonable pricing, quick in and out - I see some notes on pricing, If every time you made a transaction you called around yeah sometimes you could find a better deal - but just as often you can get better deal from him - all in all its a wash. In the long run its better to have an established relationship -
