-
March 2024 by Mitchell Mars
3/1/24 ordered 3 pizzas and they are absolutely the best thanks to the young man in the kitchen
-
December 2023 by Leann Brackney
Would recommend. Safe surroundings and friendly service.
-
November 2023 by Marrilyn “Time saved”
Very rude cashier. If you want to be waited on you have to get her attention from her phone.
-
October 2023 by Chris L.
We were in town and I needed Casey's pizza, which I haven't had for years. I got a cheese and a taco pizza. They were expensive, but they also really hit the spot. I probably wouldn't come back when I can get pizza hut for quite a bit cheaper, but it still was nice to try after so long.
-
October 2023 by Noel Ritchey
First station in town to raise gas price and last to drop it down to market rates.
-
July 2023 by James Edward
One of the biggest and nicest Casey's I've ever been to. I was amazed at how big their hot food section was. I would suggest anyone that's in Effingham to stop here. Has to be one of the best Casey's I've been to.
-
July 2023 by Amy Eastin
I got a gluten free pizza and I asked them to be careful about cross contamination and they were so kind, thoughtful and understanding about my allergy. I really appreciate when people ensure I don’t get sick!
-
July 2023 by Roamin'theslums
Employees don't care about customers I'll just go to the caseys down the road. They only take cash
-
July 2023 by Beth Mines
Always has fresh hot pizza slices......
-
May 2023 by Terry Hoffmann
There has been three different occasions I have called in a half an hour before to order a pizza so I can have it on my lunch break and when I go to pick it up it's never been made i order more faces from here recently by calling in and again my pizzas were not there now I can't even call in to the store I do not have an email address so I cannot order online I'm done with ordering from cases
-
January 2023 by amber v
spoke to someone about a mistake on a pizza. i was told they would make me the same pizza but how i wanted it. i then got hung up on. i wanted the brisket pizza with no onions or jalapeños because i’m slightly allergic to both. this is what i got.i dont think i’m getting that new pizza and i’m very disappointed that i wasn’t even offered a refund. very rude, disrespectful and unprofessional. i’m not spending $20 on pizza here again.i’m very disappointed
-
November 2022 by First “OdlySpecific” Last
Went to the Deli and got a tomato basil veggie wrap with cheddar cheese...it was amazing. Veggies were super fresh and deli artist was lovely and beautiful and did not make fun of me for having no idea what to do there.Update: never mind
-
September 2022 by Lisa Shelton Nickles
JUST CALLED THIS STATION , NO E 85 FLEX FUEL ..... SMH CASEYS :(
-
September 2022 by Amy Schultz
Tried to get breakfast before work, endedup with cold biscuits and gravy
-
February 2022 by Lori Johnson
Order a large half meat lovers/ half onion and mushroom.. received all onion and mushroom with meat lovers.Dough was so raw that it was a complete pile of mush.
