Casey's in Geneseo, IL, located at 837 N College Ave, is known for its excellent pizza delivery and pickup. They use made-from-scratch dough, real mozzarella cheese, and the freshest toppings to create delicious pizzas. Customers can also enjoy a range of appetizers, sweet treats, drinks, and grocery essentials. For added convenience, Casey's offers quality fuels for gas tanks. Reviewers appreciate the timely service and the restaurant's responsiveness to mistakes. One customer highlighted that when a delivery error occurred, the staff quickly resolved it. Another customer noted an impressive experience when they were offered a more expensive side at no extra charge after an item was unavailable. The delivery driver also promptly returned with missing drinks without needing to be contacted. Overall, Casey's is recognized for its solid food delivery service and exceptional handling of issues, making it a popular choice in the area.
Got a good pizza in a timely manner, when an innocent mistake occurred during my delivery the staff were quick to fix it
10/10 Solid food delivery choice, competitive with other options
June 2022
Friendly staff, food is good & a nice quick shop in town
December 2021
Ugh quality hot chocolate. One time the machine kinda shmooped and gave a bunch of extra powder in the cup and LET ME TELL YOU it was soooooo good. Best hot chocolate ever except for that one I made but ya know at least they got some twinkies.
