Casey's in Mattoon, IL offers an exceptional pizza experience with made-from-scratch dough, real mozzarella cheese, and fresh toppings. Customers can also enjoy a variety of appetizers, sweet treats, drinks, and household essentials. The gas station provides quality fuels, making it a one-stop-shop for all your needs. Reviews praise the delicious veggie pizza, with one customer stating it was "one of the best ever." The breakfast pizza with bacon, egg, and extra cheese sauce was also a hit, though the crust was not as thin as requested. The staff is commended for their excellent service, friendliness, and efficiency, even during busy times. Overall, Casey's in Mattoon is a reliable and customer-focused establishment, offering a wide range of products and services. Customers appreciate the quality of the food and the outstanding service provided by the dedicated team.
Edited: The manager was super responsive & made it right!!
Day 2 of no breakfast pizzas at 6:30am at this location ðŸ˜
September 2025
This location rarely has gluten free crusts available. Not an issue in Charleston.
June 2025
We frequent a lot of different locations and this Casey's veggie pizza was one of the best ever. Staying in Sullivan we had a bad experience with the food at the local Casey's store so we decided to venture out farther away. Only reason I gave them a 4 instead of a 5 is that they didn't have my free cookie!
