Casey's in New Athens is a highly appreciated gas station and convenience store known for its fresh, delicious food options and friendly service. Customers frequently visit, especially during summer weekends, to enjoy ready-to-eat meals that are always fresh. The store’s clean and well-maintained appearance, along with its inviting landscaping, contributes to a positive experience. Employees are consistently friendly and helpful, with one staff member earning special praise for his friendly attitude and interaction with customers. The staff’s kindness and dedication often turn a routine stop into a pleasant visit, even during busy moments or emergencies. The pizza and food choices stand out as a major highlight, making it a preferred stop in the St. Clair County area. Parking is typical for a gas station, and the overall environment is welcoming. Many customers appreciate the staff’s willingness to go above and beyond, making this Casey’s a place where customers feel valued and cared for. It’s a business that consistently strives to provide good service, quality food, and a positive atmosphere.
Wish gas stations had options like a farmers market with fresh, clean foods. Foods ok. The people are what make this a better choice stop. Man behind the counter always makes cheesy jokes and it makes my day. Friendly atmosphere!
May 2026
I love Casey's. This location had pizza ready and several other food options. Staff was friendly and seemed like they enjoyed working with each other.
April 2026
Mostly great staff! Food is usually very good and the odd time it's not there usually real good about replacing it.
