Casey's in Oakland, IL offers pizza delivery and pickup with handmade dough and fresh toppings, along with appetizers, wings, groceries, and fuel. However, the place is noted as getting dirtier, with most employees not being friendly and pizzas sometimes lacking cheese. Positive feedback highlights a knowledgeable and professional kitchen manager who is very respectful, works well with everyone, cares about customers and employees, and ensures orders are made on time with wonderful tasting pizza. This individual's efforts to be kid-friendly and create a welcoming atmosphere are also acknowledged.
If you find yourself in Oakland passing through, this Casey's goes above and beyond keeping the store and bathrooms clean and has excellent customer service! My 2 girls love the attention they get from the cashier's! Great Job
March 2026
Your typical, run-of-the-mill Midwest gas station with a lotta heart.
June 2024
Place is getting dirtier by the day . Most employees are not friendly . No more greeting people as they come in . Pizzas in warmer barely have any cheese on them .
