Casey's in Pana, IL, located at 1 W 2nd St, offers the best pizza delivery and pickup with made-from-scratch dough and fresh toppings. The menu includes appetizers, sweet treats, drinks, and groceries, plus quality fuel. It is a convenient stop for snacks, bathroom breaks, and gas. While the staff is generally friendly and the place is clean, there have been some mixed experiences with service, particularly in the evenings. Overall, Casey's is a reliable option for meals and essentials, making it a great place to visit for food and fuel.
The donuts from this Casey’s are the BEST I’ve ever seen from a gas station. The lady that makes them deserves a HUGE shout out. 100% Unbelievable. Check them out.
November 2025
We ordered a breakfast pizza through the app and it was made perfectly. Plenty of toppings, cooked perfect and Not greasy at all. Great job!!!!
August 2023
Much like most Casey's, a nice place to stop in for a snack, a bathroom break, and gas. The staff are usually pleasant too.
