-
July 2025 by roxanne mcmeekan
Amazing place in town
-
June 2024 by Mazzy Love
What a joke! The boys thay work the food are only interested in being motor-mouths. I had a death in the family and had to travel through Phophetstown and Caseys was a convenient half way mark. Ordered 3SANDWIHES !!! and the guys in there were blabbing their heads off and it took ALMOAR A FREAKING HOUR. Super incompetent. The boys spent 20 minutes talking to a customer friend and all he bought is a foutain soda.
-
November 2023 by Matthew Gill
There are three things I love about Casey’s food: Taco Pizza, Breakfast Pizza, and the Box Tops program. I haven’t found a decent substitution elsewhere for any of those three things. Pro-tip: if you get the Taco Pizza, ask for the chips on the side. And use the hot sauce!Service is decent here. They had a rough night once, pizzas delayed by 45 minutes, as a result of a scheduling mishap. Management gave us the order for free, and the employees offered drinks while we waited. I appreciate not having to explicitly ask for the refund.For what it’s worth, I also feel like the environment, inside and out, is safe and comfortable.
-
June 2023 by Craig Harvey
The staff themselves are decent. Store just needs a no loitering rule enforced. The group of seniors hanging out and rubber necking the teenagers every morning is beyond uncomfortable.
-
January 2023 by Kari Goodell
I am offended that key employees are treated so poorlyROBIN, deli-mistress extrodinaire was terminated due to an unforseen post operative complicationDESPITEher longevity and dedication to the company.Many, many loyal customers will not only miss her but will also refuse to support this disdainClearly corporate~ NOT a community minded
-
October 2022 by Sherry Lauts
Store in Prophetstown Illinois doesn't answer their phone half the time, very frustrating. Have been calling for 30 minutes
-
August 2022 by Corey Grawe
Good pizza friendly staff
-
March 2022 by Jojean Degeeter
For a gas station pizza, Casey's in prophetstown has decent pizzas ?. Their taco was delicious last night. We had added hot sausage to it, was not overly hot, added perfect balance. We've had pizza from all over, lastly from poor boyz in rock island, whos pizza was so bad we thru over half away. We always save our leftovers. I would recommend Casey's in prophetstown for their pizza, very good
-
November 2021 by Christine Greg Rhodes
I called at 5:31pm ordered online my delivery is supposed to be here at 6:11pm we are still waiting for our food!!! My husband is very upset and starving!!
-
August 2021 by Matthew lucas
The service was good the food was good but the only problem is there’s a lot of tattered and torn uniforms in there that’s kind of giving off the vibe that no one cares if they don’t care enough about their uniforms and what else don’t they care about it’s a bad reflection of the company
-
January 2021 by Julie Love
Not enforcing social distancing or mask policy. Witnessed 4 people enter with out mask!
-
December 2020 by Matt Martens
Always very polite and helpful employees
-
October 2020 by Francis Bridge
Well stocked, friendly associates, good pizza and clean restrooms. They did remove the seating area recently.
-
October 2020 by Kent Lewis
Nice staff good service and I like that they wear masks
-
October 2020 by Thomas Keist
Great pizza. Clean store. Friendly staff.
