Casey's in Salem, IL offers delicious pizza with made-from-scratch dough, real mozzarella cheese, and fresh toppings, along with appetizers, sweet treats, drinks, and household essentials. Customers can also fill up with quality fuel. The store is well-maintained and looks good after repairs. However, some customers have noted unprofessional behavior from staff, such as cashiers joking and holding up the line, which can be frustrating. Overall, it is a great place for pizza and quick shopping needs, with friendly service improving at times.
It's Casey's pizza. The best pizza place around. It cleverly disguised as a gas station.
May 2026
Estimated wait time on website was a 30 mins off, the dude was moving back there though. Need to implement hair/beard nets. Biggest gripe is order extra, pay extra, never receive extra. Another handful of pineapple isnt going to break the company but cmon, $1.80 for a pinch?
April 2026
Great breakfast pizza. Coffee is good. Friendly, professional service.
