Casey's is a busy establishment that has seen improvements in management and service, with dedicated workers providing a positive experience. Customers have praised the well-made pizzas, highlighting the perfect cooking and flavor. However, some have noted issues with certain menu items, like the thin crust pizza, which needs better cooking. The coffee quality has come under criticism, with reports of a burnt taste from the new machines. Despite some staffing challenges common in larger locations, the staff, particularly two caring women, have gone above and beyond to assist customers in difficult situations. Overall, Casey's offers a mix of good food, caring service, and areas for improvement.
Ordered 4 pizzas for pickup. Ready on time. Took to family reunion. They were quickly consumed. Reasonable price…they don’t presume a tip or flash a tip screen at you when completing order. Good service/product for your dollar.
May 2025
The pizza’s we ordered today 5/13 @ around 4:45 we perfectly made. Not burnt, not greasy, just the way they’re supposed to be. Great job Aidan. You can cook our pizza’s anytime.
June 2024
Pulled pork sliders are awesome. Pizza by the slice is quick, handy, reasonably priced, & tasty!
