Casey's in Sycamore, IL, located at 105 Plank Rd, is a well-maintained and popular local spot offering a variety of services. Known for its pizza, Casey's serves made-from-scratch dough with real mozzarella cheese and fresh toppings, making it a favorite for many residents. Customers appreciate the thin crust and reasonable prices, considering it one of the best pizzas in town. The business provides convenient pizza delivery and pickup options, making it easy to enjoy their delicious food at home. In addition to pizza, Casey's offers a selection of appetizers, sweet treats, drinks, household essentials, and groceries. The store is often praised for being clean, well-run, and fully stocked, with friendly staff who are respectful and helpful. A longtime cashier is especially appreciated for her politeness and dedication to keeping the store tidy. The gas station part of Casey's is generally considered clean and convenient, though some customers mention issues with pump maintenance and receipts. During busy times, staff training and order accuracy have faced challenges, leading to missing or incorrectly made pizzas. Despite these occasional problems, many customers still enjoy Casey's for its affordability and friendly service. Overall, Casey's in Sycamore is seen as a reliable spot for both food and fuel needs.
Great local gas station. Clean store. Love their food. From breakfast pizza to their burgers are worth trying. I would have given Casey's 5 ⭐s but the last time I went inside the cashier looked as if he would rather eat broken glass than help us. Other than that, I go their all the time and will return.
June 2026
They need to leave the cookies in the oven a few minutes longer they're really undercooked they don't have flavor shots for the iced tea and they don't have soft serve ice cream. Basically not even a Casey's
May 2026
Best caseys for pizza in dekalb, the other ones just dont stretch the dough as much or something.
