-
January 2024 by Grace Stambaugh
They were so polite and did exactly what we wanted for our cupcakes!
-
August 2023 by David N
My wife and I were traveling and while getting gas we stopped for a quick treat. HOLY COW. An amazing little shop. I'm glad they are so far away, I would gain 50 pounds. If you are driving thru, do yourself a favor. Stop in
-
July 2023 by Amy Biggs
I got a cake today from Simply Sweet cakes for my daughter’s birthday and I was pretty disappointed. I was scheduled to pick my cake up at 10:30am, but when I got there it was not done. The owner seemed surprised my cake was scheduled for pick up at that time. I waited a half hour for my cake to be ready, but it was missing part of the design so it looked really plain. My daughter’s party was at 1:00pm so I could not wait any longer for it to be re-done. There also wasn’t very much frosting on the cake and when I removed the fondant pieces all you were left with was chocolate cake. I would expect more from a $70 cake.
-
August 2022 by Jordan Fuelberth
We chose Simply Sweet Cakes to do our wedding cakes! They did an AMAZING job! Our cakes looked beautiful, exactly how we wanted them! They also tasted absolutely amazing! Everyone was very happy! They brought the cakes on time and they were so easy to work with! We really enjoyed it and will definitely be coming back for events in the future! They made our wedding cake dreams come true!
-
April 2022 by Daniell Scheiterle
I got a dozen for my coworkers birthday and they were all amazing in look and taste. I think price wise it's perfect and excellent quality. I will definitely be back
-
April 2022 by Denessa Bowman
Best cupcakes. Great fresh ingredients. Great flavors.
-
March 2022 by Lori Hendershott
Did an amazing job on cake for hubbies 60th birthday!! Thanks guys!! It was delicious!!
-
March 2022 by Craig Friend
Great variety of delicious cupcakes, professional staff,grandkids loved them.
-
November 2021 by Katrina Howard
They did an amazing job on my son's birthday cake. It looked great and tasted just as good. Definitely worth the 30 minute drive from Peoria!
-
October 2021 by J Lewis
Best cakes ever! He made us a rubrics cube for a birthday and an owl for a birthday.
-
October 2021 by Campbell Daniel
Simply Sweet did our wedding cake and the whole experience was fantastic!
-
July 2021 by Amanda Keller
The cake was beautiful and done for a special occasion for a child leaving foster care. When I first contacted Simply Sweet I specifically asked for whipped icing, as our family isn’t a fan of buttercream and super sweet icing. My husband picked up the cake the day before our party and when I checked it, it definitely did not have whipped icing. When I contacted Simply Sweet, the response I got was “that is sold through Walmart or a grocery store”. I would have rather gone to Kroger or somewhere different to get a cake for half the cost, because the frosting tasted like clay mixed with powdered sugar and anhydrous. Half the children that were there even threw their cake away without eating it. I’m extremely disappointed that my request wasn’t met and no resolution was given. I would have gladly taken the cake back or not ordered at all if I had known it wasn’t going to be what I requested.
-
July 2021 by Meredith Carroll
Simply Sweet Cakes did such an amazing job for our wedding. I LOVE their French Toast cake and usually it is only a seasonal fall cake but Mike went out of his way to make the French Toast cake specially for our wedding and it was a huge hit! The traditional wedding cake they offer is phenomenal with their almond twist. My husband who is not a cake person will only eat their cake. We wanted a simple design for our cake that wouldn’t melt since our reception was outdoors and Mike made it simple yet so elegant and got it safely to our reception even over all of the gravel roads. We will always come to them for our cake needs!
-
June 2021 by Krista Jobe
Went to order a birthday cake for my daughter ended up having my grandson pick out some cupcakes for everybody at the house. When I say the most delicious cakes and cupcakes they are spot on every time. They have amazing decorating skills and always have my stuff ready when I'm ready to pick it up. Only place I will order my birthday cakes or any cakes that I need for a special occasion.
-
March 2021 by Stephanie B.
We've ordered cakes from here many times and have never had issues until recently. We ordered my daughters birthday cake from here, and while the design was super cute, the taste was not. We order chocolate cake with Bavarian cream(same as we always get). The cake itself tasted horrible. Unfortunately it was hardly eaten at her party and guests complained. I thought it tasted play doughy(salty). I tried another piece the next day, trying the filling, icing, fondant, and cake separately, it was definitely the cake that tasted off. My husband messaged them and complained, they blamed it on the Bavarian cream(it was not the cream, this tasted fine), and offered a 20% off discount of our next order. We paid $60 for this cake. It would have been nice to receive part of our money back, especially considering no one wanted to eat it. It was a waste of $60.