-
January 2024 by Noty Kity
Best Pizza ever. I know what you’re thinking gas station pizza. It is very tasty, loaded with ingredients that we asked for. Freshly made in 15 minutes. Also, kudos to Sam!! She helped us with our order and brought the pizza to our truck! Thank you!
-
August 2023 by Olen T
Good pizza
-
April 2022 by Dan Shelliam
Trashiest gas station I've ever stepped foot in. Small blonde girl is flirting with every customer. Employees making out during thier shift. Is there any accountability with the staff? I just wanted a slice of warm pizza and couldn't even get that. This place used to be decent
-
April 2021 by John Stafford
They hand make their breadsticks now, and it was disgusting.
-
January 2021 by R W
After ordering a pizza online, I go to pick it up 20 minutes later and it hasn't even been started.. says they didn't hear the ticket print. Wouldn't be so upset... but this isn't the first time. Lesson learned.
-
December 2020 by carol cee
I would like to give Cody a great review. He is very helpful and so nice. The pizza we ordered was the best . It was done just like we asked.Thank you Cody , it was delicious! Very nice store and great service
-
December 2020 by LilithShaw
Great poeple even better food.
-
November 2020 by Traci Shippy
Love their pizzas and they always have my sweet tea in stock.
-
October 2020 by Quin Klammer
It was ok.
-
September 2020 by Julie Gerber
I liked the pizza.
-
September 2020 by Spring Klaus
It's close to home. Staff is friendly.
-
August 2020 by Teila Thommen
I go to this Casey’s a few times a week for different reasoning, usually to get food before work in the morning, and on this particular evening picking up a pizza with a coupon. I went in that morning around 10:30, and there were four crusty donuts in the case along with a few stray flys. This is still the morning hours and since management had switched the donuts are NEVER adequately stocked and they are all misshapen and horribly inconsistently frosted. Also this night, when going to pick up the pizza for carry out, I arrived and asked for it, (15 minutes after they said it was supposed to be done) and it was not even boxed up yet. The lady working the register went back without washing her hands or putting on gloves, and used her bare hands to slide my pizza off of the pan into the box. Then she informed me that she forgot my breadsticks, and instead of working to make it right (they were free with my coupon, the whole reason for ordering) she took my coupon, scanned it, said it didn’t work, kept the coupon, and charged full price for the pizza. She didn’t offer to resolve the issue, and when we called down to the store, she said we’d have to talk to management the next day. The few days following this incident, they have continued to not keep the donut cases stocked, and the food in the warmers looks as if it has been sitting for hours. This Casey’s is a repulsive disgrace to the franchise and you should be ashamed to be associated with it and the imbeciles they have employed. Everyone who works there is rude, unsanitary, and cannot manage to do anything in a timely or efficient manner. With the exception of the one polite man that works during the day, the only remainder of prior staff.
-
July 2020 by Barry Schliem
Caseys in Warren has been the best around when our buddy’s Tyler and Trav were back in the kitchen. Tonight however there were some new people and our pizza was awful. It wasn’t cut properly and was all over the place. Not a good experience. Bring back Ty and Trav.
-
July 2020 by Mikey Jensen
Poor new management poor employees bad service cook didnt know how to make a hot sausage sandwich dont recommend
-
September 2019 by Charles H.
We ordered a Taco Pizza tonight and picked it up at 6:30 pm. When we opened the box the chips were whole and not broke up like usual, we had some pieces of slimy lettuce, and there was no taco packets in the box. We usually have good luck with Caseys Pizza but not tonight. My wife called them and took the pizza back down to them. I don't know if this person was not trained correctly, didn't care, or was just in a hurry but this was not a good pizza. I hope this not happen again. Sincerely; Charles Hammer
