Casey's in Arcadia, IN, is known for its delicious pizza made with scratch dough, real mozzarella, and fresh toppings. Customers love the pizza for its quality and flavor, often calling it the best in the area. Many appreciate the friendly and helpful staff, who go out of their way to provide good service, even bringing food to the car for those who cannot walk in. The store is convenient for quick stops, offering hot food like chicken strips, as well as household essentials and groceries. It also functions as a fuel station, with quality fuels and discounts through apps. Customers frequently visit for takeout or delivery, praising the consistency and taste of the pizza, which has remained excellent over the years. Whether stopping for a meal or filling up the tank, Casey’s provides friendly service and tasty food, making it a favorite spot for many in the community.
their pizza is great, but the service isn't what I would expect.
December 2025
The staff in Arcadia this evening were very friendly and helpful. Our pizzas were awesome!! Keep up the great work!
November 2023
I haven't order pizza from Casey's since 2020 because I moved to Kokomo. But today I ordered three large pizzas, one breakfast sausage and two premiums and they were as good as I remember them being three years ago, delicious Pizza!!
