The Brownsburg, IN Casey's at 560 E Northfield Dr offers delicious pizza with made-from-scratch dough, real mozzarella cheese, and fresh toppings. They also provide a variety of appetizers, sweet treats, drinks, and household essentials. Customers can conveniently fill up their gas tanks with quality fuels at this location. The staff is described as great, kind, and honest, with one cashier, Alaysha, going the extra mile to return a customer's overpayment. Customers praise the breakfast and dinner pizzas, as well as the friendly staff who know their regulars well. While some reviews mention questionable activities, the overall sentiment is positive, highlighting Casey's as a reliable gas station and eatery in the community.
The restroom is small but it's a great place to stop when traveling.
March 2026
We bought a Pizza. It was Delicious. I highly recommend it.
October 2025
Casey's steps up to the plate when asked. The wheelchair ramp has been widened, and some of the worst areas of concrete have been replaced. Looking forward to more sidewalk in front of the doors!! Thank you Casey's!!
