Play It Again Sports is a premier sporting goods store in Carmel, IN, specializing in new and used equipment for fitness, baseball, softball, golf, and much more. The store offers a great inventory with plenty of top brand-name options and a nice selection of random needs. The staff is awesome, providing tremendous and great customer service. They are always eager to help, very knowledgeable, and willing to invest ample time answering questions. They go above and beyond to ensure a fantastic customer experience, explaining valuations and helping find the right equipment. The owners are very involved. The store also offers top dollar for used equipment in good condition and provides services like a tough-to-beat regrip fee.
I walked in and I was blasted in the face with good deals…
A handsome young man checked me out, a jumprope and a pack of stringy gum the kids chew these days.
February 2026
Amazing store. Everything is organized very well and spaced out well. Super selection of golf gear and very well priced. Staff, CJ, was very knowledgeable and willing to help.
February 2026
They were extremely helpful with every single thing that I could possibly need
