Chesterton Toys is an awesome and top notch toy store. It is a go-to place for many customers who have been coming for years for presents. The store has a great selection of interesting toys and puzzles of the highest quality. The items are for young minds to keep active, and you can check them out before you buy. The prices are really good and great, pretty much the same as other major retailers. The owners and staff are always so nice, welcoming, friendly, knowledgeable, and extremely helpful. They make a point to remember you and care about their customers, taking time to answer any questions. They are personable and available, helping to find the perfect toy or gift for the appropriate age group. The overall experience is very positive, and the store is highly recommended.
Loved this store!! Very cool items and a great selection of toys! The owners and employees were very helpful in identifying toys and explaining the items. Worth a stop. The town of Chesterton is adorable as well with many little stores and restaurants.
June 2026
Loved the vibe! It's not often you find a decent local owned toy shop. They were very nice and my kiddo left saying it was her best birthday ever. We will definitely be coming back here again!
May 2026
i love this place the employees were very nice and so was the owner i went there the last day before they closed and met the owner he is a very nice and friendly person
