Auto Insurance in Columbus, IN

11 locations found near Columbus

“Lindsay was the most helpful person I have had the pleasure talking to. In my 8+ years of using this company. She went out of her way to make sure I had the right policies. She even helped me with some things, I didn’t even know I needed. So for that thank you so very much Lindsay. You are wonderful.”

5 Superb161 Reviews

“Logan has been amazing to work with. He definitely went above and beyond staying late on a Friday evening to make sure my new vehicle Had Insurance after buying it!”

4.9 Superb100 Reviews

“Kasey and her team are always so helpful, supportive, efficient and friendly. I have been using her for years and she has always went above and beyond. Cannot recommend her team enough!”

5 Superb61 Reviews

“Go see Chris Bell for your insurance needs. He will find the fit that's best for you. With a thousand questions and needing insurance fast Chis delivered for us. Can't recommend him enough!”

5 Superb38 Reviews

“Kelly answered call rright away, worked hard to find appropriate supplemental insurance for me. Have recommended her to at least 5 friends.....all of whom were pleased with her services”

5 Superb25 Reviews

“After calling only 30 minutes ahead of when my daughter and I wanted to stop by, Kayla was so very sweet in offering us different options for car insurance and renters insurance. She made it so simple and easy, explaining everything we had questions about! She even helped us find a specific document on the app! We were in and out of there very quickly with her new insurance!”

4.7 Superb53 Reviews

“My experience with the Jerry Miller Allstate agency has been and continues to be overwhelmingly positive. Jerry and his team got me through an incredibly difficult time following the passing of my wife and the purchase of a new home, for which I will always be grateful.”

4.8 Superb20 Reviews

“Al Furlani and his team have been a pleasure to work with during all the years I've had auto and renter's insurance with them. Jeanne is always quick to reply and very helpful.”

4.7 Superb15 Reviews

“Paul is the best. Quick to reply and explains everything. I have been with American Family for 30 years and have never been disappointed. I used to do billing to other insurance companies and that along with the great service convinced me that I should always use American Family Insurance.”

4.5 Superb12 Reviews

“After suffering significant hail damage to my roof & back door, I couldn’t be more impressed by how quick this company was to respond & assist me with repairs. I am also very grateful to my agent for all of his assistance in finding me the best coverage for both my house & car. Great job! Would definitely recommend!”

4.2 Good26 Reviews

“I was able to get a great quality life insurance policy for myself, my wife, and my children through American family. Kyle was very professional and worked hard to get us the best policies possible for the money we could spend! Also he took the time to explain our policies in detail and didn't just leave it up to us to try and figure out the policies on our own. If I could give him 6 stars out of 5 I would ! I highly recommend talking with Kyle about any insurance issues you or coverage that you may need! Great customer service!”

3.8 Good15 Reviews