Insurance in Columbus, IN

19 locations found near Columbus
View Map

“Ryan is very knowledgeable and always provides great customer service anytime I reach out. He is always quick to answer my questions and if he doesn't know the answer is willing to find it and get back in touch. If you're in the market for insurance I encourage you to give Ryan and Acceptance a call!”

5 Superb60 Reviews

“I highly recommend Zeller Insurance. Their staff is prompt, professional, and always helpful. They truly take care of their customers.I had been a Progressive Insurance customer for several years. Progressive consistently raised my rates for no reason each year. I switched to Zeller Insurance who recommend West Bend Insurance Company. My rates are lower, my coverage is better, and the customer service is better. West Bend and Zeller have been fantastic.”

5 Superb41 Reviews

“Absolutely amazing service, Kasey and the team at her agency are wonderful. Prompt responses to questions, and willing to explain everything down to the line. Never have any concerns with my coverage on my auto or my renter's policies. So glad I made the switch.-Harlan Watkins”

5 Superb29 Reviews

“In just my first two weeks of working with Scott and Bri, I am beyond impressed with their high degree of professionalism, attention to detail, relationship building, and willingness to go above and beyond. The reason why I left my previous agent is because everything was pushed to phone apps and chatbots. In an era where things are increasingly more automated, sterile, and impersonal, insurance needs are something that I prefer to work directly and in close collaboration with a human being. I couldn't be happier with what I have found with this team! They are knowledgeable, trustworthy, attentive, and first-class in their operations. Bravo!”

5 Superb26 Reviews

“Mark is personable and genuine and I'm thankful he is my agent. Every time, I have met with Mark, I left confident about my insurance coverage and cared for.”

4.7 Superb45 Reviews

“Kelly answered call rright away, worked hard to find appropriate supplemental insurance for me. Have recommended her to at least 5 friends.....all of whom were pleased with her services”

5 Superb13 Reviews

“Heather was great. Very thorough, informative and timely.Conveyed updates regarding insurance options via video presentation which was very helpful.Would recommend Priority Risk and Heather to anyone needing insurance.”

4.8 Superb18 Reviews

“Great office to work with on your insurance needs. Staff is friendly and knowledgeable. They helped me understand the need to properly insure my family. Thanks !!”

4.6 Superb25 Reviews

“My experience with the Jerry Miller Allstate agency has been and continues to be overwhelmingly positive. Jerry and his team got me through an incredibly difficult time following the passing of my wife and the purchase of a new home, for which I will always be grateful.”

4.7 Superb15 Reviews

“Paul is the best. Quick to reply and explains everything. I have been with American Family for 30 years and have never been disappointed. I used to do billing to other insurance companies and that along with the great service convinced me that I should always use American Family Insurance.”

5 Superb7 Reviews

“I love the coverage, pricing, and most importantly the great, quick service of Shepherd. Ask for Todd Boilanger, he’s the best. All of my insurance has been a breeze for years with him on my side.”

5 Superb5 Reviews

“We've been with Bob Parker at State Farm for over 25 years! Bob and his staff are professional, friendly, and genuinely care about their customers. Their attention to detail and efficiency are second to none!”

5 Superb4 Reviews

“Al is always willing to go the extra mile!His staff is friendly would recommend to anyone! I have my home and auto with al !!Great company great prices and great service!!”

4.3 Superb6 Reviews

“This Allstate Agency has to be one of the best in the Midwest. Great customer care and very responsive to all of my inquiries. I would recommend this group of insurance professionals to anyone looking for a long term solution to their insurance needs.”

4.2 Good33 Reviews

“We have been with Gil's office for years. There has been many changes in the last few years with the office staff but one thing we can count on is Erica! She's the consent and holds the office together! We miss her sisters kelly and sheila who used to also work here. Now we mostly Janet takes care of our insurance needs! highly suggest Gil, Erica, and Janet!”

4.2 Good10 Reviews

“Rawlings Insurance has been great to work with as a business. They are local and responsive so they are there when you need them. We often have to request COI's for partners/projects and they get them sent right out. That is hugely appreciated.”

4 Good3 Reviews

“Vince and Jody are both fantastic people to work with! Every time I have needed something, it has been handled about as fast as I present it to them. Best insurance agent in town in my honest opinion.”

4 Good11 Reviews

“I was able to get a great quality life insurance policy for myself, my wife, and my children through American family. Kyle was very professional and worked hard to get us the best policies possible for the money we could spend! Also he took the time to explain our policies in detail and didn't just leave it up to us to try and figure out the policies on our own. If I could give him 6 stars out of 5 I would ! I highly recommend talking with Kyle about any insurance issues you or coverage that you may need! Great customer service!”

3.6 Good5 Reviews

You May Also Like