Insurance in Columbus, IN

18 locations found near Columbus

“Lindsay Lentz was Amazing ! She made sure that I was taken care of in a timely manner. She was so nice and helpful. She took her time finding me the right quote. She cares about people I would have thought she was a supervisor how amazing she is thank you again.”

5 Superb118 Reviews

“Kasey Collins makes the insurance process feel less like paperwork and more like catching up with a friend who genuinely wants you to be taken care of. Kasey is that rare combination of lighthearted and laser-focused—she listens, explains things clearly (without the jargon), and follows through quickly and with great attention to detail.

It’s clear she loves what she does and it shows in how she treats her clients—with warmth, humor, and heart. If you want an insurance experience that feels human, go see Kasey!”

5 Superb58 Reviews

“Greg has taken care of us for many years. He advises us on the best way to go to protect our intrest. We has never steered us in the wrong direction. We trust him completely.
Jim & Billie Helms”

4.9 Superb61 Reviews

“Go see Chris Bell for your insurance needs. He will find the fit that's best for you. With a thousand questions and needing insurance fast Chis delivered for us. Can't recommend him enough!”

5 Superb38 Reviews

“We discussed many aspects of insurance. Mark did an excellent job of explaining everything. And he even helped us download the app. Very professional and we will continue working with him”

4.8 Superb83 Reviews

“Although I did not switch to Allstate at this time, I highly recommend this location! I spoke with Lennon over the phone; he was professional, knowledgeable, and personable. Lennon helped me to understand my current policy better. He also provided great information for future policies as my assets and needs may change.”

4.8 Superb73 Reviews

“Heather at PRM was a pleasure to work with. She was able to structure new coverage that replaced or enhanced my previous coverage while saving money. Heather was very responsive to my many questions and got the new coverage in place in a timely manner. I would recommend Heather and PRM for your insurance needs.”

4.9 Superb37 Reviews

“Kelly answered call rright away, worked hard to find appropriate supplemental insurance for me. Have recommended her to at least 5 friends.....all of whom were pleased with her services”

5 Superb25 Reviews

“My experience with the Jerry Miller Allstate agency has been and continues to be overwhelmingly positive. Jerry and his team got me through an incredibly difficult time following the passing of my wife and the purchase of a new home, for which I will always be grateful.”

4.9 Superb22 Reviews

“After calling only 30 minutes ahead of when my daughter and I wanted to stop by, Kayla was so very sweet in offering us different options for car insurance and renters insurance. She made it so simple and easy, explaining everything we had questions about! She even helped us find a specific document on the app! We were in and out of there very quickly with her new insurance!”

4.6 Superb50 Reviews

“I love the coverage, pricing, and most importantly the great, quick service of Shepherd. Ask for Todd Boilanger, he’s the best. All of my insurance has been a breeze for years with him on my side.”

4.9 Superb7 Reviews

“Absolutely loved my experience and my insurance agent Mikayla! She really made everything clear for me and walked me through everything. Nothing but great things to say!”

4.5 Superb19 Reviews

“Paul is the best. Quick to reply and explains everything. I have been with American Family for 30 years and have never been disappointed. I used to do billing to other insurance companies and that along with the great service convinced me that I should always use American Family Insurance.”

4.5 Superb12 Reviews

“I have been with Chris since 1999. He’s been a great agent for me over the decades, constantly going above and beyond. I would recommend Chris to anyone with insurance needs.”

4.5 Superb9 Reviews

“After suffering significant hail damage to my roof & back door, I couldn’t be more impressed by how quick this company was to respond & assist me with repairs. I am also very grateful to my agent for all of his assistance in finding me the best coverage for both my house & car. Great job! Would definitely recommend!”

4.2 Good26 Reviews

“Al is always willing to go the extra mile!His staff is friendly would recommend to anyone! I have my home and auto with al !!Great company great prices and great service!!”

4.2 Good6 Reviews

“I was able to get a great quality life insurance policy for myself, my wife, and my children through American family. Kyle was very professional and worked hard to get us the best policies possible for the money we could spend! Also he took the time to explain our policies in detail and didn't just leave it up to us to try and figure out the policies on our own. If I could give him 6 stars out of 5 I would ! I highly recommend talking with Kyle about any insurance issues you or coverage that you may need! Great customer service!”

3.8 Good15 Reviews

“This insurance will not pay for anything. Paying top dollar for insurance to have to pay 50000 out of pocket for emergency surgery! Did not pay for any physical therapy all out of pocket!!
Update siho paid 73000. They did make it right.”

3 Average4 Reviews