-
October 2025 by Stephanie Spicer
I absolutely love my new car and Tanner and Conner were so helpful in getting me what I wanted. Great people at a great dealership.
-
October 2025 by Noah Sauntry
People are scammers, says they go by “market value” then I find the same exact car for 12,000$ less. And multiple other great deals on similar cars for WAY less money, Literally go anywhere but here. You’ll find a better deal, I promise you that. Then after having a short conversation with the person on Facebook, and I tell them I’m gonna write a bad review they block me to keep me from doing so! And I’m sure they’ll try and get this deleted as well.
-
August 2025 by Cindy Dreyer
Robby at Payton Auto in Seymour IN is the best. We bought a Cherokee in April and then I decided to see if it would swim. Stupid me it doesn't. Thank God we bought GAP insurance. My husband was able to go today and get another vehicle. Robby worked so hard again for us. Payton Auto you have a winner in Robby and that's an understatement. What he has done for us is way over and above.
-
June 2025 by RyanJen
Five stars! Absolutely amazing job to Tanner and Connor and their team for all their hard work to help for customers find exactly what they love! 🌟 🤩
-
June 2025 by Jason Vincent
Buyers beware!!! 50 days since I purchased a bike from them and still no title, no plate's and a bike i can't ride. Run far away from this dealership!!!
-
April 2025 by Randy Roberts
Great experience!! Good people!
-
March 2025 by sara deckard
I love my new Malibu! They even delivered it to my doorstep after hours!!!
-
March 2025 by Eric Francois
Great experience! Thank you for the back floor mats!
-
February 2025 by Tiffany
My second vehicle I’ve bought from Payton Place Auto in Columbus! These guys made the whole process so easy and I LOVE MY NEW EXPEDITION!!!!!
-
February 2025 by Staci Campbell
Drove by several times and spotted a blue Chevy truck. Stopped in to look at it and ended up leaving with an even nicer dodge truck! Danielle Wooton was a GREAT help! We had to drive to Columbus with her to get the truck and it was just like we we old friends! 💯 recommend!!
-
February 2025 by Cory (Grant)
Awsomes customer service and very knowledgeable.
-
January 2025 by jarrod gentry
I love my new Mirage! These guys never gave up and finally got me in something awesome!! I’ll never go anywhere else!!!
-
January 2025 by Gable Aker
I definitely would recommend Payton Place Auto to anyone who is looking to purchase a vehicle! They go above and beyond anywhere I have been to make sure you get the vehicle you need and want! They are friendly and really go out of their way to make it happen! They even delivered our car to us over an hour drive away out of their time to ensure we got the vehicle. I would give them 10 stars if I could! I will never go anywhere else to purchase a vehicle! I just want to personally thank you Conner for helping us out and getting my family and I in a reliable car! we are so thankful for Payton Place Auto!
-
January 2025 by Ariel Lynn
Tanner was amazing and got my boyfriend and I a great deal!
-
January 2025 by Gunner Haverfield
Great staff very friendly and very helpful
