-
December 2023 by G
My truck broke down and I was really cold and very hungry they let me come in and make my phone calls .when I asked where there was a mechanic in town, and they gave me the direction to the closest one where Robert Fritz was. he knew my problem right away, gave me a great deal and also fixed it and let me keep the truck there until I could get back.Anyway this was the best Subway sandwich I've ever had in the life I dare say it was the best sandwich I ever had in my life and it was full of chicken with lots of melted cheese. I didnt get to eat it for three hours snd it was still the best sandwich ever. been going to other subways to recreate it, and I'm so disappointed. I love the BMT there I've always stuck with them, but since I was just so cold out, I got that hot sandwich. actually held it near me to get warm and then later heated up microwave and it was unbelievable. I think it's a mother and daughter working. It makes me want to just drive all the way back there about 2 1/2 hours and get another. I live in Indianapolis, and there are a lot of subways here I'd like I said other than having stale bread sometimes that BMT always is excellent. but I will never forget get my sandwich in the small town, Crothersville.
-
November 2023 by Billy Jordan
Long line because of a basketball tournament. Employees worked fast and together to get us through as best as possible.
-
October 2023 by Mable Jackson
Crothersville subway is hands down the best. The toppings are fresh and the bread is fresh & soft.
-
October 2023 by Sam Dean
I wish I knew the guys name working 10-1 at 8:20pm. He was awesome - made a perfect sandwich faster than I’ve ever seen. Thank you!!
-
August 2023 by Paula Kelley
Thank you Kenzie. Wonderful experience. ?
-
July 2023 by Barbara Colwell (B.)
I haven't ate anything here but I'm eating it four stars just for the incredible cookies and the cleanliness of the store alone!
-
June 2023 by Boomer Boy 109
The lady that works mornings is very rude, I love subway but I will never go back. She should not be working with the public if she is that hateful. I left with no lunch on my lunch break, she said the toaster was broke so I asked for a cold sandwich cause I had to go, she told me no she couldn’t make a sandwich, she said it in a very rude way.
-
May 2023 by Amanda Durham
This is a super tiny hole in the wall but that keeps them on their toes. The place is always clean, the staff are clean, kind, and eager to please. All in all this subway is exactly what it started to be, fast clean and fresh ingredients! Definitely WOULD recommend!!
-
May 2023 by jessica marcott
Always a good sandwich from this store and it's never crowdedParking: Tight small parking
-
March 2023 by Scott Wells
Throwback subway still sporting original decor, but was clean and service was super friendly. Custom orders prepared right and tasted great.
-
February 2023 by Bradley Coomer
Good food good
-
December 2022 by Chris Hickman
Don’t trust the website on time open. I just went there and it was closed. They were having a Christmas party and the website and app said they were open. I went hungry
-
September 2022 by Roger Vaughn
This is truly the diamond in the little community of Crothersville. The staff is always friendly and polite. The service is always prompt and the food is always great. While this Subway is the only eat out location in town they remain grounded in their small town roots.
-
August 2022 by The Traveling Man
The footlong was ok but the environment not so much. One lady was making the sandwiches while training two older ladies. They were struggling, one was coughing then putting toppings on the sandwiches. The experienced lady was touching the register in between making sandwiches wearing the same gloves which was unsettling. I might stop again depending.EDIT -- Went back today and the lady, maybe the manager, was completely ignorant. Refused to put anything extra on my sandwich claiming they don't come that way. I thought Subway added lettuce, mayo, green pepper, etc.. if you asked for it. Well, not here and everything has went up in price. Guess I'll find somewhere else to eat.
-
August 2022 by James McCormic
Online order, missing a cup from the three combos ordered. Told one was a bottle. Showed bag no bottle, showed receipt 3 cups. Snorting sounds, yes this is true. Went back and made a minute production of taking a cup out of the sleeve. Then asked for a cup carrier, another snort. Got home and two of the three sandwiches were double meat, all the same , didn't fill 2/3rds of the bread.You will never see a dollar from me again. I'll drive to a Jimmy John's
