February 2023 by Andi Ann
The manager said 2 mins, the second we walked in the door.. we said, what does that mean? It was only 8:55pm on a Wednesday. He said, we are closing, it felt very rude to be honest. He could of politely said, we aren’t open much longer. I am in customer service and let me tell you, I never leave reviews often. This was awful. No wonder we don’t frequent this place ☹️
December 2022 by Darieba Antonio
The pizza here is so amazing, the ladies at the front desk are so friendly and say good morning to everyone that walks the the door. The employee that make the breakfast are so kind and always have everything filled so I never have to wait. Thank you all so much you are very appreciated.
December 2022 by William Johnson
I like this place. Priced are reasonable staff is great, and the food is really good.
October 2022 by GoodMorning World
AMAZING PIZZAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA!!!! Eat here! Don't look at the prices! Look at the... PIZAAAAAAAAAAA!!!
August 2022 by Chere Engstrom
If you want to be talked down to, cussed at, treated like overall dirt, AND called racist this is the place for you. If not stay clear as their night shift manager seems to think it's ok to treat a customer with zero respect and wonder why they are upset and wanting to speak with the store manager. I shop here every 2 weeks for my smokes and will now go out of my way to get them elsewhere. I'd give negative stars if I could.
June 2022 by Jeff Tompkins
Wanted to order a pizza. I called 3 times in 10 minutes. So i just went to store to place order. Couldn't find cook. So went to front register to place order. Cook was up front talking to friends. Than preceeded to tell me it was a 25 minute wait. Couldn't answer phone and didn't want to take order because was to busy talking to friends. Pizza in warmers looked dried out and old. So i just left and went to pizza hut.
May 2022 by Anti Treason Channel
Called at 8:58pm. Says open till 10pm....lied about delivery. Don't go here or order from here. Laziness is a reflection on food.
May 2022 by I Drink And Know Things
Called at 8:58pm. Says open till 10pm....lied about delivery. Don't go here or order from here. Laziness is a reflection on food.
April 2022 by Hannah Deisinger
I love your pizza but I came in and ordered a bacon breakfast pizza and I got a mostly sausage, and a little bit of bacon breakfast pizza. Sad moment.
March 2022 by Marco Lucciano
Normally This is the best Casey's to get pizza from but this pizza I just got was dry and orange like it was someone's pizza that didn't get picked up and was left our for hours it was so gross it makes me sad. Like I've never had a bad pizza from this place till today. Idk what happened it was just awful
March 2022 by Chris Craig
I haven't been to this store in a while . Was VERY disappointed in my experience. Food was old , cashier was a zombie with no customer service skills whatsoever
December 2021 by Jennifer White
We ordered pizza and cheesy bread. Person who answered the phone needs better training on how to take an order. She didn't not apply the cheesy bread to the order. We where unable to wait for it to cook. Then the pizza is way under cooked. The crust is so flimsy it does not hold the ingredients on the pizza. WORST EXPERIENCE EVER!!
September 2021 by Thomas G.
As of late, the shelves are bare, the food is scarce and when the food is available, it's awful, and the coffee taste bitter with the new machine. This has been the issue since June. During the pandemic, they managed to be stocked and have delicious hot food. Since the manager was replaced it's gone downhill. The Nappanee St store is much better.
September 2021 by Casey G
Great pizza ?, good deals and service. Thank you Casey's.
July 2021 by Brian Peachy
Very Friendly and curtious
