Casey's in Elkhart, IN, located at 3704 South Nappanee St., is a convenient and friendly local spot that offers a variety of services. Known for its pizza delivery and pickup, it features made-from-scratch dough, real mozzarella cheese, and fresh toppings, making their pizzas a popular choice. Besides pizza, the store provides appetizers, sweet treats, drinks, and household essentials and groceries. The food section is well-stocked with a good variety of items, including wraps and subs, though it doesn’t have veggie trays. The store is always clean and organized, creating a pleasant shopping environment. The gas station part of Casey's is considered one of the nicer ones, with friendly staff who are always cheerful and helpful. Customers appreciate the great service, often mentioning how staff go above and beyond, such as remaking orders if needed. Despite higher gas prices typical of the area, the overall experience is positive, with many customers expressing satisfaction with the friendly staff and quality offerings. Casey’s combines good food, helpful service, and convenience in one location.
