-
February 2024 by Ariel Stumpf
Staff is kind, but the ice cream cake is pretty bad. The cake inside it was insanely dry, overall flavor isn’t great. Icing on top tasted like food dye. Definitely not worth $40.
-
January 2024 by Judeana
The serving size is extremely small. I got 3 bites out of one scoop. If I would have known before I ordered I would have went to Handles. The ice cream was good but I will never waste my money here again. Their serving size was equivalent to a sample at Handles or Cold Stone.
-
January 2024 by Judeana Patton
The serving size is extremely small. I got 3 bites out of one scoop. If I would have known before I ordered I would have went to Handles. The ice cream was good but I will never waste my money here again. Their serving size was equivalent to a sample at Handles or Cold Stone.
-
December 2023 by Min X.
The Brownie sundae was good, the waffle bowl was good. The spoon was too soft though!
-
November 2023 by joec171
This place is AMAZING! Awesome ice cream and employees are super ! Excellent coupons and rewards too! Love it !
-
November 2023 by Linda Hanks
This place has some of the best ice cream I've ever had. My favorite flavor has to be the chocolate peanut butter with buckeyes. The brownie flavor was great too, especially with added peanut butter sauce and reese's cups.
-
November 2023 by Nick Staker
We were on a trip to indy and decided to stop here. The ice cream was yummy and service was relatively quick. Price was reasonable. Only outdoor seating and it was pretty cold out…hence the 4 stars.
-
October 2023 by MSRcpa
Love the ice cream. Great flavor and great variety. They even have a “no sugar added” flavor. However, I won’t be back! We have been here several times. The problem: our treat always costs $5.50. They do not provide silver back as change. So, my treat cost $6.00. Picky, I know, but been here six times and not once did they round down!
-
August 2023 by Jon Clegg
Bruster's is a family favorite now. This one takes priority over the others. Sometimes, we just have to switch it up, but rarely is that a mutual feeling. So we go here 99% of the time.A+ Flavor/service.
-
August 2023 by Chef D.
VEGANAll Vegan Ice Cream Pie- Mint Chocolate ice cream center with vanilla ice cream, layer chocolate fudge and chocolate graham crust. DELICIOUS I SAY!!!!
-
August 2023 by Jenna K.
Mmmmm. Brusters is very good! I would say it's a little much expensive than some of the other shops around but it's good! My favorite flavor so far has been a seasonal one that was a almond wedding cake flavor with black raspberry jam in it. Please bring it back and I will come daily!!
-
August 2023 by Nicola Abney
This place is great!I will say yesterday they only had the side windows open which made the line awkward and the umbrellas were up on the tables which made the lines even more awkward. Cramped for space.
-
July 2023 by Sheree W.
Stopped here to try out this new Icecream spot.I arrived around 7:30 and there seemed to be a decent amount of people as though they all had the same idea, to get Icecream after dinner. It's located right off Olio in a strip mall. There are other businesses there so the parking lot was pretty full although parking didn't seem like too much of an issue. This is one of those places where they don't have inside seating so when you order and get your treat, you have to find a seat outside which they have 3 or 4 tables out there or take it to go. I'd say the best thing about this place is the fact that they have non-dairy oak milk Icecream as an option and it's actually really good. Great addition to this area of Fishers.
-
July 2023 by Jaykob Egg
REALLY good and fun place to visit! Their ice cream is soo good. If you have dairy allergies you won't be disappointed and you have multiple options to choose from!!! MUST GO PLACE!!
-
June 2023 by Adrian A.
Great ice cream with great service! As of recent Bruster's has been my go to for quality ice cream and I love that they offer both traditional and non-dairy (oat milk). My go to flavors have been the Key Lime (Traditional) and the Cookies & Cream (Non-Dairy). Both are great in their own way, especially during the hot summer months. Service is provided through a window but they do have a few tables/seats outside. If you are ever in the Fishers area and are looking for a quality treat, check out Bruster's!
