Pet Supplies Plus Fishers is a neighborhood pet store that has everything you need for your furry, scaly, and feathery friends. Their shelves are stocked with a wide selection of natural and made-in-the-USA products, offering you the right products at prices you love. Whether you shop in-store or use their convenient online services like free curbside pickup and same-day delivery, Pet Supplies Plus makes shopping local simple. Customers praise the store's extensive selection, including accessories like cat trees, not just the typical food and treats. They also appreciate the competitive prices, especially on premium brands like Fromm dog food, and the excellent rewards program. The staff are consistently friendly and professional, creating a "pawsome" experience for both customers and their pets. Reviewers highlight the store's clean and organized layout, making it easy to find what they need. They also commend the staff's helpfulness, with one customer praising a cashier named Cecilia for her exceptional service and warm, welcoming demeanor, even while dealing with a personal injury. Overall, Pet Supplies Plus Fishers is a trusted and beloved pet supply destination in the community.
This location has super friendly employees and good prices. We save on pet supplies using their coupons in the mail.
December 2025
Love this location. Very clean and friendly staff.
September 2025
Young worker helped me with my new kitten i found. ♡ so helpful! Didn't over sell me (to much) lol but I got everything i needed it one stop thank you!
