-
January 2026 by Reynold
Great food & great service. Very noisy, so hard to talk, especially if you have hearing aids like me.
-
January 2026 by Curt
Always great food, beverages, and service. (Although last night's pizza was lukewarm, at best...must've sat for a bit) It's pretty noisy inside. If you want to have a conversation, outside seating is best. Great dessert options...if you've saved room.
-
January 2026 by Tim
Absolutely delightful food. We chose to go there to celebrate a birthday and we were not disappointed. Very unique flavors. Thought it was interesting that it is located so close to Mama Corollas. I think they're both excellent. You go to Mana's for very traditional food. I found this to be very traditional as well, but with a slight experimental uptick on the flavors. 
-
December 2025 by mark
Dinner was great. Pizza was amazing. Mushroom risotto was a bit too al dente for me. It was grainy and the mushrooms were not cooked properly I'd go back for the pizza anytime.
-
December 2025 by Matt
Had reservations, was seated inmediately. Server was exceptional. Food was delicious, and served with a very small wait. Will be back soon.
-
November 2025 by Kelly
Our first time at Diavola but definitely not our last! Very friendly, attentive service without hovering, good menu with food that took us back to Italy! Such a great neighborhood vibe. A bit loud but still able to carry on a conversation.
-
November 2025 by James
Our group of three needed a relatively quick dinner before attending a performance a few blocks south. We chose Diavola because we could get a reservation and we already knew the menu choices. Our server, Julian, was spot on in helpfulness. Our food was excellent. Our wine choice was terrific. And Julian got us out in plenty of time to make our curtain.
-
November 2025 by Jim Harper
We love Diavola. We are regular customers. Everything we've ever had has been delicious. Their menu items are great, and we love any specials we've tried. Tonight we had the pistachio encrusted tuna with homemade pasta. It was wonderful!
-
November 2025 by Brian Danielian
Great pizza! Loved the food and service. Highly recommend.
-
November 2025 by Ashley Norton
The best pizza place I've been to in the US! Authentic real Italian style pizza. The crust🤌 was so perfect, slightly chewy like perfectly risen yeast with a slight crunch to the crust. No soggy dough over here!! The bottom wasn't overly done either. I will travel the 1.5 hours or takes to eat this pizza, it's that good.
I also appreciate the sauce, it wasn't too sweet or tangy. It was savory.
The desserts- the gelato with cocoa powder, the cheesecake and tiramisu to freaking die for. Gelato was smooth and Rick but not overly done, it was sweet without too much richness. The cheesecake, thick and creamy with a sweet graham crust and then the tiramisu- fresh, fluffy, creamy melt in your mouth perfection.
The Service was great, our waiter brought out the food as it was ready, he gladly took photos and was quick to refill drinks. Loved his vibe and the way he treated us!
Can't wait to go back!
-
November 2025 by Wendy
Our server was perfect! 21st birthday experience was great for our niece and entire party.
-
November 2025 by KarenR
Great food, good portions. The salmon with lobster risotto sauce was perfect. Saw other patrons with the wood-fired pizza and it looked great too! Service was excellent. Lively environment.
-
November 2025 by Andrea Harlan
I had the best pizza I’ve ever eaten in my life here. We aren’t from Indianapolis but will come back just for this pizza.
-
November 2025 by Rian Fitzgerald
Holy Cannoli and The Diavola pie!
-
November 2025 by Rebecca
Love the food here and have been many times, but the service last night was sooooooo slow. I know the kitchen had a lot of to-go orders going through, but to have the kitchen be so backed up for the dine-in customers that it takes over an hour to get our food was just frustrating. Our server did apologize, but he left us waiting for uncomfortably long periods of time wondering if/when we could order and also where our food was in the process. I asked for a to-go box and he took my pizza away to box it up and 5 minutes later still hadn't returned so we left (we were in a rush at that point). On the way out, we passed our waiter who was talking to someone out front, so he wasn't even in back boxing up the food. I wondered how much longer we would have had to stand there waiting if we had waited. We had a 5:30 reservation and ended up being late to our 7:30 show because, despite being sat at 5:32 and ordering by 6, our dinner was served at 6:55 (the waiter knew we wanted to be out of there at 7pm and 5:30 should dinner should have been plenty of time). Super disappointed.
