-
December 2025 by Jill
Our server was terrific- attentive but not pesky. Our entrees - salmon and a ribeye were cooked as requested and the food arrived in an expected sequence and timing i.e. appetizer- pause- entree- pause desert. As simple as this seems most servers can't make it happen! Thank you H&I for a delightful experience. Worth the price
-
December 2025 by Lorraine
St. Nick's Lodge was magical! Decorations were beautiful! Just wish it was warmer to be more comfortable.
-
December 2025 by Edgar
Steaks are great, aged ribeye and new your Izzy's special are outstanding! Shrimp cocktail has a very peculiar flavor sauce which is not spicy it's crazy hot, like ginger overload.
-
December 2025 by Kelly
We had a friend dinner and it was great! Jen was our server and she was fantastic! Food was so good and environment was very pretty! It's a little pricey but you know that going in!
-
December 2025 by Shelly
My Favorite Place Always! My husband and I would celebrate every special occasion at Harry & Izzy's. He passed away in July of 2023 and the celebrations STOPPED! But for me, I still enjoy coming into the restaurant for a nice glass of wine and an amazing dinner with a friend, while talking about my beautiful husband. Thank you for giving me this place to revisit my beautiful memories with him.
-
December 2025 by Mike
Food and spirits were excellent - service as always was wonderful. Great way to celebrate a birthday!
-
December 2025 by Patricia
We were celebrating my husband's birthday, had requested a quieter area , and a table rather than a booth. All requests were fulfilled, and we enjoyed a wonderful lunch, plus a complimentary dessert to bring home and enjoy later. Our server was Sga'Quia T, and she was friendly, helpful, professional and fun! We will definitely return for another special occasion.
-
November 2025 by Elizabeth
Disappointed to arrive and find out that St Nicks lodge wasn't open and that's what our reservation was for. However LJ at the bar was able to make some delicious drinks.
-
November 2025 by jon
We regularly eat at H&I and have rarely been disappointed. Sadly, some cost cutting was apparent in reduced portion size and reduced menu selection even as prices have increased. And, what bar does not have dry vermouth. It's a staple! Hopefully, our next visit will be better.
-
November 2025 by Stephanie
The service was excellent and the ambiance was just right. I was celebrating my birthday and the team prepared a card for me.
-
November 2025 by chastity
We had a horrible experience on Saturday. I let the restaurant know in advance we were bringing a 3 year old. The booth was not set up at all for a boater seat. We let the waitress know we had to leave for our train ride. Food took over 50 minutes to be served. Very very disappointed in how this special occasion we communicated in advance was handled by the staff.
-
November 2025 by Courtney
The service at this restaurant is outstanding-our server (LJ maybe?) was kind, attentive and offered great recommendations. We enjoyed the cute festive cocktails. The cozy Christmas décor adds an extra layer of charm and perfect photo ops. It's a little chilly in St. Nicks Lodge but that's to be expected, dress warm :)
-
November 2025 by Crystal
From the greeting of the hostess to my departure the dining, the experience twas top shelf. A must boast about the French onion soup. Yumerful!
-
November 2025 by Kay
Our waiter was great! My French onion soup came out barely warm. Power kept going on & off.... Wasn't the best experience. We were celebrating 3 family birthdays & we probably will be choosing a different resturant next year.
-
November 2025 by Dave
Great experience, excellent service all around, and the food was delicious. Our party had a few kids and the staff was great with them. Their kids menu is excellent also. Will be back
