-
March 2024 by Bill Strode
Came for a special dinner. Very Very nice. Private rooms are private and quiet, didn't know there were other people there until we came out. I've never seen shrimp that big. Very good food, nice atmosphere. Nice place for a celebration or romantic evening.
-
March 2024 by Craig strubel
I have a lot of allergies they took care of
-
March 2024 by bryon thomas
Ruben went above and beyond to accommodate us for our first year anniversary.Our waiter Bill was very friendly and informative.Thank you for making this an anniversary to remember!
-
March 2024 by Charles Edwards Jr
Over the past year my wife & I have been trying all sorts of new places, that we stumbled across in a foodie group, but when it came down to choosing a place for our anniversary dinner.. we picked a familiar favorite.. Tony's Steaks & Seafood. The food is consistently excellent. The service & ambiance is top notch as well. If you've never been, I'd suggest you give them a shot.. ask for Alexander Williams, he'll take good care of you. Next year we plan on finding more hidden gems to try out, but when another special occasion rolls around.. chances are we'll be back at Tony's..?Parking: They have metered spots on the street, but we usually do the valet parking
-
March 2024 by Emily B
We came here for a birthday with a group of 7 and everything was amazing. Drinks were well-made, food was stellar, and our service was great. The server recommended many dishes and it was a very enjoyable experience. I would recommend a reservation and to come early to find parking. There was live music and it was a nice atmosphere. They also have some of the best mashed potatoes ever!
-
March 2024 by Dawn Marie
Came there with friends to celebrate my birthday. The staff was fantastic and the food was amazing. Ruben was awesome and gave us suggestions on where to go afterwards. This is definitely at the top of my list for dining and I will be back. I've been telling everyone how great Tony's is!
-
March 2024 by Cathy Norman
Had dinner with a friend. We both loved everything.. The entire staff was very attentive. Recommend for sure!
-
March 2024 by Indy317
Alexander was our server and made every part of the meal a special experience. Tony's menu is exceptional but the service takes it to an entirely new level. Alexander is also a sommelier and takes the time to share wine recommendations and to also share information about regions and topography. We will return and will continue to bring friends and family so that they can have a special experience too.
-
March 2024 by
I can't gush enough about how amazing my experience was. I was dining alone taking a break from WTW2024 to enjoy a meal. Man oh man - Alyssa waited on me and it was such a fun time. The tartar is the best I have ever had. The mussels with little strips of chorizo was yummy. I was almost in tears enjoying the flavors of everything I ate. Going back Friday night to try more!!
-
March 2024 by Uzuri Jackson
Tony’s was AMAZING! Our Bone-in Ribeye was a chef’s kiss; perfectly seasoned and cooked to our liking. The crab cake was also phenomenal. If you’re looking for the best steakhouse in Indianapolis, come here! You won’t be disappointed.
-
March 2024 by
Tony's was AMAZING! Our Bone-in Ribeye was a chef's kiss; perfectly seasoned and cooked to our liking. The crab cake was also phenomenal. If you're looking for the best steakhouse in Indianapolis, come here! You won't be disappointed.
-
March 2024 by Awesome
We have never had a bad experience at Tony's of Indianapolis. Everyone was extremely gracious and kind. We will be back and in the meantime we will continue to tell everyone how awesome Tony's of Indianapolis is and try should try it.
-
March 2024 by Tamara Artis
Had a party of 13 for my bday on Feb 25. Never been before and was really disappointed. Server was not that friendly and my streak I order a 9 oz sirloin medium well can back medium rare. Sent it back then came out well and not as juicy since they recooked same steak. I feel you pay $60 plus for a steak you should cook a new steak. Other party had issues with the bone in Ribeye wish was market price also. Party of 3 cost $417. Never again Ruth Chris/St Elmo no issues ever. For the price they should have a cooker, oven broiler etc that know what temp to cook a steak. Then waiter messed up all our receipts had other peoples drinks/food on everyone elses tab??
-
March 2024 by Joey Grove
Was an awesome
-
March 2024 by SusanR
3 of our 4 steaks were not cooked properly and the flavor was not up to Tony's standards. Very disappointing evening we all were so excited and then deeply disappointed. The cost of the evening was expected however, the poor quality from our experience was not expected.