Casey's in Kokomo, IN at 3016 S Webster St offers delicious pizza with made-from-scratch dough, real mozzarella cheese, and fresh toppings. They also provide appetizers, sweet treats, drinks, and a variety of household essentials and groceries. Customers can fill up their gas tanks with quality fuels as well. The staff is known for their excellent service and positive attitudes, particularly the manager Kendra. However, some customers have expressed frustration with the lack of restocking certain items they regularly purchase, which has impacted their overall satisfaction. Despite this, Casey's remains a popular destination for the community, as evidenced by their Veteran's Day initiative to provide lunch for local veterans.
Best pizza I've had in area . Plus the woman who made it is really nice I forgot to add extra sauce to order. She gave me a cup of it for free.
August 2026
Staff is very welcoming, wish manament would give them more help sometimes they get behind more 25 minutes when waiting on a order but not the staffs fault they try their best with the resources they givenā¤
December 2025
This a convenient store/gas station that has some of the best pizza 's in Kokomo. The pizzas are made fresh and to order with a good variety of specialty pizzas
