Casey's is a great place with friendly and helpful staff, providing great service. The store is clean and the pizza is amazing. Burgers, popcorn chicken, and breakfast burritos are delicious, along with unique items like everything bagel cashews. It is recognized as the best value in town for gas prices. Customers note that the hours online should match the actual opening times. The main drawback mentioned is that there is only a location in Lafayette, not in West Lafayette.
Easy entrance, easy to find what I wanted and quick cash out.
April 2026
Casey's in Lafayette Indiana is one of my favorite stations. The employees are super kind and helpful. I only get my ice, I like to eat it, from there. They have the best pop machine ice around!
April 2026
They actually have pretty good pizza. The cookies are AMAZING! My favorite food item from there is actually the bacon macaroni and cheese, a meal within itself.
