-
November 2023 by Makenna Stidham
We had Carey cater the desserts for our wedding and everything was delicious! We had cupcakes, cookies, chocolate dipped strawberries, and some truffles. Everything was a hit with our guests and we loved all of it! Personal favorite was her snickerdoodle cake flavor, which we ended up doing for our personal wedding cake. Prices for her desserts were great too! Loved it!
-
June 2023 by Anita Barrientos
I saw the pictures of the cakes on google and they looked really great so I decided to order 3 dozen cake pops from them. I am all for supporting small businesses!Here is my review:flavor - ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ (ordered caramel, red velvet, and vanilla)cake consistency - ⭐️⭐️ (a bit dry)overall appearance - ⭐️ (chocolate is really thick and clumpy, they’re not round, drizzle is only on topcustomer service - ⭐️⭐️⭐️ (I asked to pick them up 3 hours earlier than I had asked for and they were done! ?? but the color I had asked for was sage green and beige and the green is just not the right one ?I am sure their cakes are amazing, the pictures are beautiful and they have great reviews! This is only my opinion on the cake pops ?
-
October 2022 by Rayanne Broadway
Our wedding cakes were certainly made with love. They were on time, kind, and efficient.
-
July 2022 by Kyli Marshall
I ordered a Mario Cake for my sons 4th birthday, it was decorated AMAZING! 100% recommend! They are so talented! Thank you again!
-
October 2021 by Karly Blair
Carey did my wedding cakes and cupcakes! She did an amazing everything was delicious and gorgeous! Highly recommend her!!!
-
October 2021 by Nikki Russell
Delicious cake and beautifully decorated!
-
September 2021 by Lexi Wilson
Seriously the best cakes! The last 5 years I’ve ordered cakes from here for special occasions! Just had a birthday party today and was impressed like always! So good!
-
July 2021 by Heather Salyer
Carey made my step son an awesome custom cake for his graduation/going away to Army party. I showed her a pic off Pinterest and she exceeded my expectations. Everyone couldn’t get over how cool the cake was! 5 stars all the way!
-
June 2021 by El Catracho Mazizo
They are the best … they did a cake for my wife birthday and look amazing..
-
June 2021 by Ashley Cole
she does amazing everything my daughter absolutely loved her birthday cake and everyone at her party said how amazing it looked and tasted.. I almost didn't even want to cut into it it was so beautiful!!! I highly recommend cause she's just all around amazing
-
February 2021 by Cherish Ann Hollowell Caldwell
I love this lady and her cakes she is BRILLIANT THE CAKES ARE MOIST
-
January 2021 by Kassandra N Handshoe
WE USED HER FOR MY SONS FIRST BIRTHDAY CAKE... BY FAR THE BEST CAKE I'VE HAD. WE ALSO INTEND TO USE HER FOR OUR WEDDING THIS YEAR!
-
August 2020 by L R
We have ordered cookies multiple times from Carey's cakery, they are always helpful and go out of their way to make the perfect treats for your party!
-
November 2019 by Nicole Studeman
Owner was very nice and extremely helpful.
-
May 2019 by Amanda S.
I'd more specifically give a 3.5 star rating, if that was an option. We've been looking for a new pizza place for a long time and we were hoping this would be it- it's not. The toppings were good but neither my husband or I could really enjoy the crust. It's dense and much more...cakey? It wasn't a good crust to topping ratio and it just felt like you were eating some sort of shortbread with pizza toppings on it. It didn't feel like we were eating a true pizza. However, their baked goods- buckeyes and brownies, were really good. Rich, great flavor and texture. Everything seemed reasonably priced- my husband did comment that the inside reminded him of antique shop with the carpeting inside. We're hoping to try more from this place- we like supporting small businesses!
