Casey's is a popular and well-liked store known for its good food and drinks. Customers appreciate the cleanliness and friendly staff, often comparing it favorably to other local convenience stores. Many enjoy the breakfast pizza and find the service to be better than nearby competitors. However, some reviews mention issues with the store's cleanliness, especially in the drink area and bathrooms, which have been described as dirty and grubby at times. One reviewer noted that the tea had an off flavor, but overall, the store is seen as a nice place with good food and friendly people. Customers express loyalty and hope for continued improvements, appreciating the kindness and good experiences they've had there. Despite occasional concerns, Casey's remains a favored spot for many in the community.
Love their food never had anything bad there.... their pizza is amazing I add pickles with my pizza
March 2025
Wasn't sure what to expect after reading other reviews, but I found the inside of the store to be clean and in really good shape. I used the self service soda fountain, and everything seemed to be in working order.
November 2024
Good service here. I always stop at Casey's for gas when I'm going through Madison.
