-
November 2025 by Nikola Lukic
Had 3 sets of tires installed by Tieman Tire in the last 3 months. I supplied the tires each time and bring them in loose.
First set on my Equinox: Installed good, but we’re counter balanced like crap. Had to ask to rebalance and literally hawked them to make sure they got it right. Kept telling me “machine is chasing weight”. Made them balanced then till they hit it right. Tires shook like crazy, ended up driving to Evansville to Discount tire to have them balanced properly.
Second set: 19.5’s for my dump truck. I had bought retreads and knew they wouldn’t balance well. Got home to install onto the truck, lowered the truck, two tires de-beaded instantly. These boys filled the 19.5’s up to 30psi. Like they blasted them on the changed and didn’t care to fill them up afterwards. They should be at 105… Had to bring to a local shop in Loogootee to reseat the beads. Wasted my time and truck was down, couldn’t work.
Third set today: trailer tires. Nothing crazy, just 15’s. Thought to myself maybe third times a charm. These boys tried to give them to me unbalanced. Told me “we never balance trailer tires”. For $120 for labor I was pissed. I asked them to balance, they said “they are chasing weight”. Took the trailer for a spin just now, shakes like crazy. I’ll need to drive an hour south to DT again and pay for more labor.
These boys are fast, but either have beat up uncalibrated equipment or just don’t care. I don’t think I’ll be back for any more labor or to purchase tires. I don’t like bashing local small businesses but after 3 strange/sour experiences I felt the need to write a review.
I worked for Discount Tire for 6 years when I was younger. My expectations are probably higher than Tiemans regular customer. Been a tire tech all the way up to a manager. This type of service just isn’t acceptable to me. Take pride in your work, these boys don’t.
Use Tieman at your own risk. For an old junker or beater work truck I’m sure it’s a fine shop. Anything commercial, nice, or brand new… don’t bother.
-
October 2025 by Derek Stutz
Always appreciate the service from Tieman Tire,
-
September 2025 by Josh E. Padgett
Great Service and Selection. Work was Great!!
-
September 2025 by Chandler Staggs
I went when for a tire repair they did a good job fixing the tire then I asked for a rotation they put the right front on my right rear then right rear on right front and same way in the left they broke my wheel stud off my right front by cross threading it with a air impact red flag #1 then I got to leaving and on my way home my wheel is wobbling look at it they cross threaded 2 out of 3 lug nuts had left now I’m down to 1 lug nut and they costed me 700$ don’t go to tie and in Mitchell, IN for anything i don’t care if your tire is blown and the next tire place is in Bedford you’ll make it -1,000,000,0000,000,000,000 stars
-
July 2025 by Amanda Scudder
Quick, efficient, fair, and friendly! Has a temperature controlled waiting area to sit in.
-
May 2025 by Logan
I had a better experience here then Big O's in Bedford.
-
March 2025 by Denny Corbin
Got me right in, then stood around chatting outside, crew looked lost, sent me down the road with lug nuts barely on. Wouldn't send my worst enemy there. By the way, I've been doing business with tiemanns for 30 years. Good job guys!!!
-
March 2025 by steve larsen
Busy place good place to get tires. They hustle and get the job done
-
December 2024 by Sam Bunjan
Tieman's ALWAYS works to ensure you receive great customer service, their prices are very competitive, and the work is done fast and with an emphasis on getting it done right the first time, every time. I'll tell you a strong enough terms do not go anywhere else but
-
November 2024 by K \u0026 J Pilot Car Service
Old school tire shop. 1st come 1st serve
-
July 2024 by Donald Parrish
Do good job
-
July 2024 by Leah Moorman
Stopped by to get my tire patched up after work on a Friday night. They got me in and out quickly with my 9 month old baby. We waited in the air conditioned waiting room until they were done. Fast and cheap! Thank you for your service!
-
July 2024 by James Howell
Great local business
-
June 2024 by Maria
The guys were pleasant and extremely helpful. Thought I needed an alignment with a new tire and ended up just needing the tire. Good price on the tire as well.
-
June 2024 by Tory Moody
Fast Professional. And fair price.
