-
January 2024 by Nick Upchurch
My complaint is not with the price offered for the set of magic card my friend and I brought in, but the judgement I could sense from the gentleman working. I don't know if it stemmed from a bad day or a contempt for people who aren't avid board game players in their mid 3os but I felt unwelcome from the moment I walked in. I guess it's just not a crowd that feels comfortable with outsiders.
-
December 2023 by Aaron Lindburgh
I’ve know Wizard’s keep since it existed in the Village down a flight of stairs back in my college days and have always been impressed by the owner’s knowledge and obvious care of gaming. If you are a hardcore board game nerd you already know about this place. As it should be.
-
September 2023 by Hellranger DX
I've been shopping here for YEARS. It has definitely changed over the years, but that doesn't mean the quality has gone down. You can sometimes find some buried treasure in there, loose miniatures, single MTG cards, TTRPG books old and new. It's a fun place with a slightly old school vibe NOT trying to be comic con. Go here and buy stuff.
-
September 2023 by Eve S
This store has been around for a long time and has a pretty decent selection for a small gaming store in Indiana.
-
September 2023 by Cao Cao
Very dirty and dusty. All the items that were in plastic had brown dust and a layer of grime.
-
May 2023 by Rocket Redmon
One dollar for 1 card. Trying to get rid of my cards in Muncie is useless. Disappointed in Muncie
-
May 2023 by Donnell Boykin
My daughter and I went in about 30 minutes before they closed. I really try to leave a little before closing time mainly because in a normal store I feel rushed. This was NOT the case here. The guy was very nice and patient as my daughter was looking through the D and D die. Very pleased
-
April 2023 by Jennifer R
It's not the best but it's not the worst. There are a lot of structural problems with the building and you could see they experience(d) a lot of flooding. It made me wary to buy board games near the bottom of shelves. There wasn't a big variety but I imagine in time it will get better. The staff was very friendly.
-
April 2023 by Pirate Pete
Definitely the coolest card shop around! The owner is super nice, helpful, and very knowledgeable about magic the gathering. I also traded in a card and got WAY more for it than expected. I highly recommend this place for all your mtg cards (huge selection of singles and booster packs and etc.) and various tcg accessories. They also have a huge selection of table top games. Love, love, love this place!
-
February 2023 by Brimstone Pyro
Great selection and the open gaming area helps keep the gaming community alive. Really appreciate the space and will continue to give business to a place that offers space for ppl to come together and play.
-
February 2023 by Cole Pratt
Super friendly staff in a nice relaxed atmosphere!
-
January 2023 by Redglory Franklin
Loved the store, nice and neat. Owner was there, great guy. Great experience!
-
November 2022 by Michael Hespe
Sports cards pokemon cards magic cards and comics! This place is the best!
-
November 2022 by Kalip Hall
I've been here multiple times over multiple years and it's always been an amazing experience. Great prices and even better managment.Not to mention the comunity is here is stelar. They taught me how to play magic in 2019 and I can't stop.
-
November 2022 by Gary Keisling
Went here to purchase 10 sided dice for a school project. Exceptionally pleased with the customer service and selection.
