Toy Stores near New Albany, IN

10 locations found near New Albany

“Went in for the first time and was greeted immediately and was told where to look for what I was looking for. She came out and checked on me and offered assistance. Prices were great and I couldn’t have been happier with the whole transaction. I will be back.”

4.6 Superb66 Reviews

“I moved to Michigan for a few months, and although Detroit has Blick, there’s just something about Artist & Craftsman back home that I miss that just isn’t the same here. Is it the friendly people? The way they display their items? The vast variety of supplies and trinkets? All of the above??? I absolutely love this location for all my art supplies! Highly recommend for all types of artists, beginners too!”

4.9 Superb191 Reviews

“We absolutely love this store! We come in as often as we can to see what new games or collectible things they have, and always end up leaving with more things than we planned. The owner and staff are so friendly, and they know their stuff! If you’re looking for cool video games, gaming collectibles, or just vintage / cool things - go check this place out !!”

4.6 Superb109 Reviews

“Super friendly and welcoming staff. Well lit and clean store. I love how organized the bulk bricks are. Great place to pick up off pieces, retired sets, or special minifigs.”

4.6 Superb88 Reviews

“My family found this gem about a year ago and so glad we did! There is something for the whole family. They have a wide arrangement of retro games and gaming systems as well as new. Funko pops, comic books, and trading cards. The staff is always eager to help and very friendly. Prices are very reasonable as well. I’m a Disney adult and this store is my playground! Do yourself a favor and go check them out.”

4.3 Superb141 Reviews

“If you are looking for great deals for your family, home this store has the best sales. I love coming not only to shop but also to spend time on important home decisions.”

4.2 Good230 Reviews

“We love, love, love Kiddo!!!! It's the cutest store I have ever come across for kids. The clothing is so stylish, unique and fun for kids of all ages. It's also a great place for a baby shower gift for a friend as well.”

5 Superb18 Reviews

“Ollie’s Bargain Outlet is a well-known discount retail chain offering a variety of brand-name merchandise at deeply discounted prices. With its slogan, "Good Stuff Cheap," Ollie’s provides a treasure-hunt shopping experience, featuring everything from books, toys, and home goods to flooring, electronics, and seasonal items. Much of their stock comes from overstocks, closeouts, and buyouts, allowing the store to sell quality items at a fraction of the usual retail price. Ollie's stores have a no-frills, warehouse-style layout that reflects its commitment to low prices over flashy displays. The brand’s quirky, fun vibe—personified by its mustachioed mascot, Ollie—adds to its appeal for bargain hunters who enjoy discovering great deals on a constantly changing selection of products.”

4 Good123 Reviews

“Went to this store before Christmas and it was a little messy. Which is to be expected with tbe holiday season. Went back after Christmas and everything was back to organized and put back on the shelves. Took my daughter's there for their first time and they loved it. We were greeted at the door and welcomed in with a smile, like family would be. Great job store staff. We will be shopping here more often. Thank you.”

3.9 Good143 Reviews