Casey’s in New Castle, IN, located at 3100 S Memorial Dr, is known for its great pizza delivery and pickup service. The restaurant offers made-from-scratch dough, real mozzarella cheese, and fresh toppings, ensuring quality pizza. Customers also enjoy a variety of sandwiches, appetizers, sweet treats, drinks, and household essentials or groceries. The store provides fuel for vehicles, making it a convenient stop for many needs. Reviews highlight the good pizza and excellent sandwiches, though some mention prices are a bit high. Delivery is fast and reliable, with some orders arriving early, and the delivery drivers are praised for being polite and friendly. Staff members, including those working late shifts, are often recognized for their friendliness and helpfulness, with employees going out of their way to ensure customer satisfaction. Despite occasional comments about long lines at the register, overall, customers appreciate the friendly atmosphere and quality service at this location. Casey’s is a popular choice for quick meals, groceries, and fuel in the area.
Nice store, one of the favorites. Awesome products and their own brand is excellent
June 2026
This place makes some goooood pizza. Totally underrated! And they keep the place nice and clean and there is always goodies on sale. Totally recommend!
June 2026
They’ve pulled me away from Speedway and have got my business.
