Thrift Stores in New Castle, IN

3 locations found near New Castle

Filters
Rating
Distance
  1. 605 New York Ave, New Castle IN 47362

    4.8 Superb 30 reviews

    “Place was nicely organized with scratch and dent household items. Everything from nails and screws to kitchen sinks. If you have a house, come check it out. The prices are great and the workers were super nice. Will go back.”

  2. 511 North Memorial Drive, New Castle IN 47362

    3.9 Good 68 reviews

    “I love stopping by here when I’m in New Castle. The store is always clean and beautifully merchandised! I came in underprepared today looking for a dresser - Markie (sp?) was so kind and helpful to me, even while taking care of other customers. She deserves her flowers! 💐”

  3. 1719 South Memorial Drive, New Castle IN 47362

    3.4 Good 84 reviews

    “Very nice goodwill!! Prices are true goodwill prices and that’s hard to find! It’s a clean and organized store with friendly staff. The items were nice aswell and a large selection!”

Advertisement