-
March 2024 by Phil Nolen
Had to wait 20 minutes past pickup time. They don't care at all.
-
February 2024 by Chris Prinzing
Great quality, they just seemed a bit chaotic. Recent change in management is most likely the cause, I'll definitely try again.
-
February 2024 by Karen Miller
Ordered our pizza by phone, was told 30 minutes. Went to pick it up and was told it would be 20 minutes more. Waited 20 minutes, went in and told it would be another 15 to 20 minutes. I told them just to cancel my order. Doubt I will be back. Basically it was going to be an hour and fifteen minute total wait time. I'd been fine with that if they told me that to begin with.
-
January 2024 by Dan Murrell
Put a future order in which was 3pm and was pick up was 6:15pm went to go pick up order and they haven’t even started it yet. And the lobby was full and said it would be an hour be it was made. Terrible service. Do not recommend this location.
-
January 2024 by David Lehr
Food was hot and fresh. Service was not the best, considering the rush being new years eve. Expectation of an overcrowded lobby and lower than usual service wasn't a good combination for a great experience. Out of the five large pizzas ordered,we all enjoyed it, as it was quite delicious.
-
January 2024 by Don
These guys always do a great job for me whenever I visit. Yes, they are busy, and it's a lot of work to work there! However, I find that they make my pizza correctly.Parking: Parking does get busy as there is not much room, but I usually find a spot!
-
January 2024 by Petulant Queen
Who owns this franchise? They charge for those little packets of red pepper lmao talk about chintzy!!! Wont be
-
January 2024 by Jason Evans
Very tasty
-
December 2023 by Ann Wayne Bailey 4ever
very nice staff and pizza was
-
August 2023 by Shelley Strode
orderd a pepperoni pizza its was a mess and pepperoni very salty First time at newburgh PJohns it was terriableI hated disappointing my 4 year old grandson of a pizza he asked forEvansville (first avenue) is much betterAs much money as they are please get it right!
-
July 2023 by Bryon Hensley
Skimping on sauces a lot, barely any in pizza when I ask for extra, and the cups when I order extra are less then half full.
-
April 2023 by Melissa Shelton
Relaxing atmosphere. The breadsticks are delicious as always. I actually prefer them to any other pizza place in town. We got the Hawaiian Luau (minus the almonds), and it was so amazing. The pure cane root beer and orange cream soda is delicious, too. Absolutely no complaints here. Thanks for the good food.
-
March 2023 by Derek Miller
Service was fast. Only complaint would be my parmeson bread sticks were pretty dry and didn't have much of the flavor on them. But they were busy so I don't fault them.
-
February 2023 by Lisa Prescott
I can't say enough good things a lot this papa johns. My order is always right and usually done early. My food is always hot and delicious. The staff are polite and courteous. The deals are always great. Thanks for the excellent job papa johns! Pics are of the Philly cheese steak pizza and cheese sticks. Yum!
-
February 2023 by Kimberly C
Deliver drivers are your customer also. We drive to get orders for your restaurant and your cant even match an online price for a pizza for us. Thank you (not) for appreciating the drivers.
