-
March 2024 by Brian Mothers
I’ve had Italian food and I’ve had Italian food this place is without doubt the best Italian food I’ve had in my
-
March 2024 by Rob
By far the best place to get Italian food. Way better flavor and value than Olive Garden by far. Been going here for 5 years and will never go to another Italian restaurant.
-
March 2024 by Katresha T.
Had Michaelangelo's for the first time and not sure why I have waited so long. First off our waiter was fantastic. He was friendly and had a great personality . I feel like good service is definitely harder to find these days, so when you do get great service it really leaves a strong impression. So that alone will make me a repeat costumer. Second, I thought the food was reasonably priced for an Italian restaurant and was overall good. Honestly, the salad and breadsticks were my favorite. Even though the ambiance wasn't anything special, the service and food is enough to have me coming back for seconds.
-
March 2024 by Megan N.
Not only was the food absolutely incredible, but the service? It felt like going to an old friends house for dinner that you haven't seen in 15 years and their mom is the sweet lady who makes everything from scratch. Our hostess (Jordan) was so incredibly kind that it felt like I'd known him forever- and even checked on us throughout our meal and after to make sure it was a good experience- and our waitress was not only kind, but also super informative about the menu & knew what all the best choices were. We will 1000% be coming back here again & may just have a new favorite place!
-
March 2024 by Nyoka W.
I can't say enough great things about our experience! The service was great - the server, Madison, was super kind and attentive. The manager, Jordan, came by to check on us to make sure we were having a great experience. The food was delicious. You can tell they make everything in house. We had the mushroom ravioli and the spaghetti. Both dishes were top notch! The environment was clean and organized. We will definitely be back!!
-
March 2024 by Zack Jellison
I’ve been going to michelangelo’s since i was a kid! this place is awesome! food is stellar, pasta always hits and salad is mouthwatering! The dressing is 100x better than any chain italian restaurant! Madison was an amazing server and was so polite and genuinely happy to be there! Great experience 10/10
-
March 2024 by Chad Humes
They have the best Alfredo sauce around. Great food and great service.
-
March 2024 by Julia A.
My brother visited me from New York for a few days, and after a long search, we decided on Michaelangelo' to build our own pastas. We called and were able to make a reservation for the same day. We were kindly greeted and our server gave us our water, drinks, and appetizers within the first 10 min. For a Friday night, the restaurant was not too loud, and did not feel too crowded. The salad and breadsticks that were included as part of the "build your own pasta" choice were my favorite part of the meal. The salad was dressed heavily but it was good, and the breadsticks tasted like Olive Garden (which I love). The calamari was not the best; it was flavorful, but the breading was heavy and it was a bit gummy. Lastly, our pastas came out quickly after, and were not too bad. I got pesto as my sauce, which I wouldn't repeat because of how greasy it was. I'm aware that pesto is mostly olive oil, but the amount compared to the herbs and garlic was just overwhelming. Other than that the food was great and we had a good time. I'm giving them 4 stars because for the price, the food was appropriate!
-
March 2024 by Shannon K.
This is one of those lovely little restaurants that you are excited when the secret gets out for everyone to enjoy. Love the breadsticks and lasagna. They have been a staple in Noblesville for many years.
-
March 2024 by mashedchicken22
Went in on Friday and couldn't believe the service that Sophia provided. My timbers were shivered, and my socks were literally knocked off (freaked me out honestly). Couldn't recommend it enough. 5 stars.
-
March 2024 by Gigi Gordon
We ordered take out and absolutely loved it!! I used to work at the Plainfield location back in High School. I was hoping it would be the same food and it was❤️. The Alfredo sauce is amazing!! I recommend getting extra for dipping the breadsticks in. The lasagna is amazing too!! We will definitely be ordering again very soon!!!
-
March 2024 by Swanney
Soup and salad combo is always a good option. Their baked rigatoni came out exceptionally hot this time, which was nice. Usually is not as hot (temperature wise) as it should be. First bowl of soup was more than lukewarm but not hot, second bowl was better. Still need more garlic on their breadsticks, but weren't as dry this time!
-
February 2024 by Monika S.
Great food and great service! My husband had the lasagna and I had the truffle mushroom chicken pasta. We both had the salad and breadsticks. Everything was really tasty. We really like this restaurant. We would have enjoyed the meal more if the music had been more mellow--there was some overly energetic sounding modern jazz playing when we first got there. After a while it thankfully improved to something more relaxed and Sinatra-era. Make a reservation on their website if you're going later than 5pm because they fill up fast. If you join their rewards club you will get a discount on your next meal.
-
February 2024 by Maria White
Great soups!!
-
February 2024 by Kaylee Parkos
I absolutely LOVE Michaelangelo’s! The food is very tasty, the service is awesome, and I enjoy the quaint atmosphere! Definitely recommend for someone wanting to support a local business!Vegetarian options: There’s many options for vegetarians!Parking: Not a huge parking lot by any means, but I’ve never been when it’s super busy, so I’ve had an easy time parking.Wheelchair accessibility: Very accessible for wheelchair users.
