Casey's in Oolitic, IN, offers delicious pizza with made-from-scratch dough, real mozzarella cheese, and fresh toppings. The menu includes a variety of hot food, breakfast, and lunch options. Customers appreciate the good service and friendly staff, along with affordable gas prices. The store also provides snacks and household essentials, with a candy section for kids. While parking is limited, Casey's is wheelchair accessible, making it a convenient stop for everyone.
A very nice little gas and convenience store. The hot food is prepared well and hits the spot for a quick breakfast or lunch.
June 2026
Store hours say they close at 10:00 p.m. yet sweet tea is put up for the night by 7:30pm. Been in there twice the last week and I won't waste my time anymore. Used to be a regular customer. I'll make the drive to Orleans or Mitchell when their store opens! Oolitic used to be a great store!
May 2026
Please have more cheese pizza slices in the warmer.
