Crystal Springs Creamery is a delightful, hidden gem and a high quality dairy store in a quaint country atmosphere. It is a beautiful place with nice people and always friendly service. The business offers a wonderful selection of dairy, meat, and home goods, alongside a nice selection of products from others, like a smaller version of a well-known essenhaus in town. Customers love the fresh milk, ice cream, yogurt, and other products, describing the milk as tasting real and more real than any store-bought milk. The ice cream is amazing, the milkshakes are amazing, and the cheese curds are great. The egg nog is delicious and comes in a glass bottle. It is farm to your table Amish quality goodness. Families enjoy getting ice cream cones and eating outside at the picnic table. Some customers note the prices could be lower and request the elimination of food colorings in certain products, like the mint milk, to provide healthier alternatives. Overall, it is a great dairy and a place people love and recommend to everyone.
They have delicious and wonderful products and friendly staff
April 2026
Piña colada float was amazing! There were lots of people but we were out in the time needed and we got to sit and enjoy the ice cream. Only thing that might have been better is the parking situation and the GPS does not take you to the right place.
April 2026
I love their milk so I decided to go out to their creamery today and found some BOMB ice cream called peanut butter Oreo. Phenomenal
