Casey's is a conveniently located restaurant that offers good prices and a rewards program. The establishment is well-lit, clean, and provides friendly service. It's a popular stop for fuel and food, especially for those traveling between Monticello and Wabash, Indiana. The menu features a variety of fresh foods, including the iconic breakfast pizza, which is a customer favorite. Additionally, Casey's has recently introduced breakfast burritos, although availability may be limited at certain times. Despite some inconsistencies, Casey's remains a reliable option for a quick and satisfying meal or fuel stop.
We ordered a pizza from here (large, thin crust, supreme). We have always been very satisfied with the quality, taste, and value of the pizzas we have received when ordering from this Casey's location.
August 2026
Good selection and quick in and outs but the morning kitchen staff isn't very organized or don't want to hustle or whatever the reason but breakfast items are hit or miss and they act like it's a hassle to make anything for you so I usually hit taco John's instead.
July 2026
After attending and event and making the travel back to near our hotel it was late and we seen they had food options. Both the store clerk and the lady who took our order and made the food were super. The pizza and cheese bread were fresh made, our wait time wasnt long at all and the cost was super cheep!
