-
March 2024 by Cindy Blaylock
First time eating here and it was great. We ate all the food we ordered and didn't get the pictures.It was busy, but our waiter was very attentive and we lacked for nothing.I highly recommend El
-
March 2024 by Christopher Danner
Neat interior, good food, staff seemed unhappy
-
March 2024 by Eric Robinson
Ok y'all, I live in Texas, was in town to visit my sick dad this past week and had the opportunity to check this place out. Wow y'all. Some of the best Tex Mex I have had. Full stop. The rice and beans are just excellent. The salsa is amazing, and the chips were light with the perfect bit of salt. And y'all, please don't even get me started on the Queso. I can say that El Potro is truly an excellent choice. Had the spicy chimmi (on special for like $9). I liked it so much that the next day when my wife got into Plainfield, I told her that I had a new place to take her. I wanted to try more of the Mexican side of this TexMex as to compare it to what I get at home. So I ordered a tamale, chili relleno, rice and beans while my wife had the Acapulco. Damn y'all. Homemade tamale's are easy to get in Texas, and a staple. These were no different. So many places outside Texas, and some inside Texas, have these little somewhat anemic looking corn straws with little resemblance of any meat....not here. The tamale was Texas sized. Like they all should be and very typical of homemade. Every thing was excellent....again! Attention to detail is what sets this place apart.Large portions and You know when the small things are done very, very well, i.e., rice, beans, chips and salsa, the rest of the menu falls right in line. To top it off, the service I got both days, was top notch. Full knowledge of the menu and able to answer any questions without hesitation. The menu is vast and I didn't see immediately see what I wanted on the menu. So I just told the server what I wanted and our server put it together and I was charged right at the same price as other combinations. Had conversations with both servers and they were so nice and a pleasure to talk to. I really hope y'all enjoy El Potro and stop in for a bite. It will be the last time you ever have to search for good TexMex. You will know where it is. Right there on west 40 just inside Plainfield from Indy. A big thanks to the servers there at El Potro. We really enjoyed eating and talking with y'all and look forward to our next visit. God bless.
-
March 2024 by Randall Corson
Food was good.Service was sporadic, had to ask for everything including refills.
-
February 2024 by Valecia Wadsworth
I tried the Texas taco. It was huge and it was wonderful. It had lots of veggies that had lots of meat and the cheese was wonderful. YumVegetarian options: Veggies nachos, veggies boritos. The people are very accommodating for off menu ordringParking: No problem finding a parking spotKid-friendliness: This is a family place and have many menu choices for kids.
-
January 2024 by shelley george
Many mexican restaurants are the same, but that is not true at El Potro. Their dishes are crafted deliciously with their personal touch in flavor and presentation. Their prices are on point for the quality of food you receive, and their staff is friendly. Do yourself a favor and visit El Potro - you will see the difference.
-
January 2024 by Bill Felker
Great food at a good price.
-
January 2024 by Mr Redd
The shrimp tacos are ? ?
-
December 2023 by Dan Nicholas
Best I have been to in a long while. Food good and hot. I had the Acapulco. Decore was nice. Furniture real sturdy unlike other Mexican places. Very full crowd for lunch but they had plenty of servers to handle it without missing a beat Muy Bueno!
-
December 2023 by Steven Calvert
Food used to be great. The portions sizes have decreased a lot while the prices have gone up. This was my favorite Mexican restaurant. The service also started getting bad. The waiter didn't come back to the table until he gave us our check.
-
December 2023 by Cory Zimmerman
I had the Burrito Verdo and it was very good. I'd definitely get it the next time I went if it wasn't for the fact I want to try their other Burritos as well.
-
December 2023 by Jordan Ramsey
Ordered to go and the salsa spilled in the bag right after walking out. Jasper was quick to take care of it so it wasn't a mess to deal with in the car. Food is great and people are too. Definitely recommend coming here.
-
December 2023 by Amy M.
The Chicken & Rice Soup is where its at!!! Ive had other things as well like enchiladas, tacos, nachos, etc. everything is good but that dang Soup is amazing.
-
November 2023 by Jerimah Cooper
Food was very good and quick.
-
November 2023 by Luis Rodriguez
Chicken soup ? so
