-
July 2025 by S A
Ordered two pizzas tonight. It took an hour and 25 minutes to receive them and they were so under-baked, it was disgusting to try to eat them. Either they need to turn the oven up higher or bake the pizzas longer. This was a total waste of money. Go anywhere but Rushville Casey's.
-
May 2025 by Mr Munsel
I've always had good service there.
-
April 2025 by Mary Tichenor-Young
Wonderful and helpful, friendly. Excellent service and phenomenal quality food.
-
April 2025 by Norm Carmony
Got the biscuits and gravy it was wonderful, the new biscuits are great, will definitely get this again, and donuts are really good also
-
February 2025 by Jennifer Steele
Extremely rude managers. Dirty bathrooms and the kitchen staff is extremely lazy and don't care about customer service.
-
October 2024 by Robert Zehr
It's a convenient gas station
-
February 2024 by Clair Starkey
Third time in a row our pizza was made wrong deliberately. We order half sausage and the other half pepperoni. Every time we pick up both toppings are on the whole pizza. We don’t have many options in this town so we try again because we like the pizza. Employees need to learn to read or be dismissed. We pay good money for food and it’s not about the customer at all. Very sad that a simple order gets made completely wrong every time. Management does nothing to make it right. Might as well close down the store and stick to gas pumps
-
January 2024 by Kelly Ross
Great customer service
-
November 2023 by Marc Baker
They refused me my free veterans fountain drink can’t believe I was refused. A drink on Veterans Day when it’s posted I will receive 1
-
November 2023 by Dillon Dunn
Store is clean and staff are
-
September 2023 by Brittany Hankins
Quick and friendly as always! Daily customer!!
-
September 2023 by victoria hall
Old woman in the deli was rude when I was trying to buy pizza out of the warmer. She told me I was buying too much and that it was for customers. She must not have realized that I was a damn customer ?
-
July 2023 by Skylar Balistrire
They never answer their phone called over 20 times.
-
June 2023 by Kay Sue
I like pizza. Pizza is good.
-
March 2023 by Pfft
Who woulda thought a gas station would have the best pizza in town.
