Casey's in Salem, IN offers pizza with made-from-scratch dough, real mozzarella cheese, and fresh toppings, along with appetizers, sweet treats, drinks, and groceries. Customers appreciate the friendly staff and clean store environment. The pizza quality is consistently good, though some find the prices for gas to be higher and the rates fluctuate frequently. The store also sells household essentials and groceries, and has a well-stocked fridge. Overall, Casey's provides reliable pizza, helpful service, and a variety of products for convenience.
Food is typically pretty good, gas is more expensive here than most other places in town. Never consistent either, as it jumps up and down 40ยข at a time but overall not terrible.
June 2023
Their pizza is awesome. On the thinner side and crispy. Also good specials now and then.
June 2023
Went in for night crawlers. They had plenty. Fridge seems to be cooling again. The worms were alive. Pleasant woman on register.
