Casey's in Santa Claus is a convenient stop offering gas, groceries, household essentials, and quick food. The store is noted for being very clean and providing nice, polite, and amazing service. It features a well-stocked and very clean coffee bar that is a highlight for many. The pizza is a standout item, described as the best, with hot and fresh slices that are perfectly made, featuring made-from-scratch dough, real mozzarella cheese, and the freshest toppings. Beyond pizza, the location offers appetizers, sweet treats, drinks, and a good selection of grab-and-go items like pre-made salads and sandwiches. Customers appreciate the quality fuels available, including E85 gas at a lower price. However, some reviews note that there can be a lack of selection of fresh food and that the kitchen can sometimes be slow. Overall, it is considered a good place to stop for quick, decent food and essentials.
We stopped here because we needed gas and wanted to see what Santa Claus, IN was about. The restrooms were in really bad shape, floors sticky/walls covered in exactly you’d imagine. However, donuts were great, and gas filled up quick.
June 2026
Friendly gas station attendants and good pizza. Good place to stop if nothing else is open.
August 2025
It's the first time we had been in this store. We heard the pizza was amazing. Well I can officially say it was awesome . The service was great , he was very nice and informative. The place was clean and very sanitary, it even smelt good. Definitely will be back again. I recommend try the pizza!!♥️
