Casey's in Spencer, IN, located at 639 W State Hwy 46, is known for its made-from-scratch dough and fresh toppings, offering a delicious pizza experience that families love. The taco pizza is especially praised as a standout dish. Customers appreciate the pleasant service, with some staff members going above and beyond to rectify issues, such as equipment malfunctions leading to missed orders. However, recent management changes have led to some dissatisfaction, including the loss of online ordering and earlier closing times. There have also been complaints about food quality, particularly with pizza that arrived raw. Despite these challenges, the commitment to customer service remains a positive aspect of Casey's. Alongside pizza, the store provides appetizers, sweet treats, drinks, and essential groceries, making it a convenient stop for various needs, including quality fuel for vehicles.
Good food, good service, and squeegees to remove bugs from my car
April 2026
I know Casey's isn't everywhere yet but, if they were, you could set your GPS to a Casey's and it will take you close enough to wherever you want to go!
February 2026
They have some very good and big tenderloins they are awesome... And the pizza the pizza is way better than Pizza Hut and Pizza pantry and I can't remember the other ones but it's really good for being gas station made lol
