Casey's in Terre Haute is a convenient stop offering pizza delivery and pickup, featuring made-from-scratch dough, real mozzarella cheese, and fresh toppings. The location also provides appetizers, sweet treats, drinks, groceries, household essentials, and quality fuels. Many customers appreciate the unique food offerings, good coffee, and the availability of decaf. The store is noted for being almost always clean. The staff, particularly the counter workers and ladies, are frequently described as very nice, wonderful, helpful, and kind. There are accounts of them offering encouraging words and going out of their way to assist customers in distress, creating a supportive environment. A new manager is also acknowledged as being very helpful. However, one employee in the kitchen is consistently described as rude, grouchy, cranky, and aggressive in his speech, which has been an issue for some customers. Despite this, the overall service from the rest of the team receives positive recognition, with many expressing thankfulness for the store and its generally helpful staff.
This pizza at this location knocked it out of the park. I actually had the 25th street a couple days later same order and what a difference this location was. I'll definitely be returning here to order my pizzas! Nice work pizza staff!!
March 2026
Very friendly staff member at the register. I go there twice a week for their caseys rice crispy bar. Unfortunately they are frequently out of it though.
November 2025
So thankful for Casey’s stores. Almost always a clean men’s room and almost always paper towels instead of blowers. I appreciate that. Unique food offerings and good coffee. I’m thankful for decaf because I don’t do well with caffeine. And no CoffeeMate brand creamer, which is tainted with aborted fetal cells.
