Casey's is a friendly and welcoming store with a clean environment and helpful staff. Customers appreciate the warm greetings upon entering and highlight the excellent service provided by employees. The store offers a variety of food options, including pizzas like the popular BBQ pulled pork pizza, which many wish could be a permanent menu item. Some reviews mention the limited-time availability of certain items, such as brisket pizza, which customers find disappointing. The food quality is praised for being flavorful and not too greasy, with toppings just right. In addition to food, Casey's provides fuel, mainly regular unleaded and diesel, with a few noting the absence of premium fuel. The store also stands out for its inclusive environment, with staff members who are kind and accepting. Overall, Casey's is seen as a reliable, friendly place to get gas and good food, with attentive employees making it a favorite local spot.
Stopped here and got breakfast pizza and two coffees and always a great place.
Filled up and love that we can get and add points when we are traveling
December 2025
Friendly staff in bicknell Jeff in the pizza AREA IS GREAT
August 2025
Went there today around 3:50pm to pick up pizza. A worker had his teenage friends hanging around and you can see them in the back taking stuff off the shelves and eating it. Plus they was in and out of the store getting in people's way. Pizza was great by the way.
