Casey's in Wanatah, IN, located at 12011 South Us Hwy 421, is known for its best pizza made from scratch with fresh ingredients. Customers appreciate the delicious pizza featuring real mozzarella cheese and a variety of toppings. The store also offers appetizers, sweet treats, drinks, and household essentials. Fueling up with quality gas is another convenience available at this location.
While the food is generally well-received, some customers have reported issues with service. Experiences at the checkout have been mixed, with some staff being friendly and professional, while others lacked a welcoming demeanor. The facility is noted for its cleanliness and large variety of snacks. However, there have been complaints about the availability of certain items, such as donuts and sandwiches, suggesting the kitchen may need more staff.
Despite some service challenges, Casey's remains a popular stop for fresh food and gas, with many praising the quality of the pizza and the overall cleanliness of the facility.
I usually like going to this Casey's, but yesterday, just as I was about to trade in my car, I stopped to put in $10 of gas. However, the pump would NOT STOP no matter what I did. The pump was messed up and cost me an extra $30. I won't be going back for gas any time soon.
October 2026
We are from the south and went to visit family and the pizza was amazing and pretty affordable will go back
